Charity which helps disabled people find work unfairly sacked employee after she suffered stroke, tribunal finds

Business & Finance
19 Nov 2026 • 7:39 PM MYT
The Independent
The Independent

The world’s most free-thinking newspaper

Charity which helps disabled people find work unfairly sacked employee after she suffered stroke, tribunal finds

A charity helping disabled people into work has apologised after it was found to have unfairly dismissed a catering manager eight months after she suffered a stroke.

Ann Moye asked her bosses at the Shaw Trust for more time to recover from the serious medical condition, suggesting she begin a phased return in two months’ time.

But she was sacked from her job at Palmers Gardens cafe in Trowbridge, Somerset, on the grounds of capability, namely her ill heath.

After an employment tribunal found she was unfairly dismissed, the Shaw Trust issued an apology this week.

The charity was also found to have subjected Mrs Moye to disability discrimination by failing to make reasonable adjustments to allow her return to work.

The tribunal heard Mrs Moye had a passion for her work and had wanted to return, and that the dismissal had affected her recovery.

Ann Moye worked as castering manager at a Shaw Trust-run cafe at Palmers Gardens in Trowbridge, Somerset (Google)

A spokesperson for Shaw Trust told The Independent: “We recognise that ending Annie Moye’s employment in October 2024 caused her deep distress, and we are sorry for that.

“Shaw Trust takes matters relating to health, disability and workplace support very seriously. The tribunal identified failings in how this case was managed, and we accept that we should have done more before Annie’s employment was ended.

“Further occupational health advice should have been obtained, and greater consideration given to a phased return to work plan. We recognise we fell short of the high standards we set ourselves and that our colleagues expect of us.”

Mrs Moye, the tribunal heard, had joined the Shaw Trust in 2006, and was working as catering manager at the cafe when, in February 2024, she suffered the stroke and commenced sickness absence.

After her statutory sick pay entitlement ended in August 2024, she was invited to a formal ill-health capability meeting in the October, where she said she was keen to return to work, but was not strong enough to do so before Christmas that year.

She suggested she could come back on a phased return in January, and explained she had an appointment with her stroke consultant three days after the meeting.

However, the Shaw Trust said there was no reasonable timeframe for Mrs Moye return, and that even with reasonsable adjustments, she would be unable to return to her current role.

The employment tribunal in Bristol recorded that the Shaw Trust did not wait to obtain a report from the upcoming appointment with the stroke consultant, which was to say she was doing “a lot better”, before making its decision to dismiss Mrs Moye.

The Shaw Trust employs nearly 5,000 people across the UK, and provides services to people who are disabled or otherwise disadvantaged, principally to help them find employment or to develop work and independence skills (Social media)

The charity also did not obtain a further occupation health report.

The tribunal judgment said: “Mrs Moye considered that she could return to work in the foreseeable future, specifically, as part of a phased return to work, starting just over two months after the date of dismissal. This, in our view, was a quite practicable rather than a fanciful or optimistic position for her to take.”

Mrs Moye did appeal against the dismissal, and a hearing was held where she reported further progress on her recovery, and again suggested a return to work in January, starting at 20 hours a week. But the appeal was dismissed.

Evidence to the tribunal from the Shaw Trust heard how Mrs Moye’s absence had put a strain on the cafe operations with it having to close one day a week, and that it was making a loss.

But the tribunal panel recorded in its reasons for judgment: “Whilst we accept that situation could not go on indefinitely or without some plan for return, we observe that a phased return can offer some light at the end of the tunnel for the employees who we are told were under strain and gradually increasing support for them may allow the cafe to continue functioning whilst supporting Mrs Moye back to work.

“Further, Mrs Moye had suggested a plan where she would return just after Christmas, a relatively short time in the grand scheme of her absence.”

The tribunal said the charity should have undertaken a proper and full assessment of what Ms Moye could do, prepare a return to work plan and at least try a phased return plan with any reasonable adjustments, before deciding to dismiss her.

The Shaw Trust had an income of £291m in the year ending August 2025, and employed almost 5,000 people, according to latest accounts submitted to the Charity Commission. Of its employees, eight receive annual benefits of more than £150,000 a year.

The charity spokesperson said improvements had been made to processes since Mrs Moye’s dismissal, including ensuring relevant medical evidence is provided, investing in additional reasonable adjustment support and increased training for line managers.

They added: “We are also reviewing this case in detail to make sure we’re learning from it and continuing to strengthen the support we provide to colleagues.”

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved