
MANILA, Philippines — Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense panel presents three senior trade and health officials on Friday as the Senate Impeachment Court convenes for Day 45 of her impeachment trial to scrutinize the operations of a Davao-based banana chips exporter linked to her husband Manases Carpio
The three witnesses will testify to rebut allegations under Article II of the Articles of Impeachment, which accuses Duterte and Carpio of allegedly accumulating over ₱817 million in unexplained wealth and failing to fully disclose assets in her Statements of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth (SALNs).
Witnesses on the Stand
According to the defense’s manifestation before the tribunal, the officials were subpoenaed to authenticate the legal standing, product approvals, and export promotions of Cale88 Foods Corporation:
• Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo (Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary and Board of Investments Managing Head): Tapped to testify on Cale88 Foods Corp.’s official business and investment registration.
• Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan (Food and Drug Administration Center for Food Regulation and Research Director IV): Summoned to authenticate the firm’s FDA product registration for its sweetened banana chips.
• Lawyer Eva Marie Mariquina (Center for International Trade Expositions and Missions representative): Appearing as a substitute for CITEM Department Manager III Rowena Mendoza to present official communications and invitations sent to Cale88 for international food expositions.
Meanwhile, the court ordered Duterte’s spokesman, lawyer Paolo Panelo, to explain his public criticisms of senator-judges, including accusations that some members were biased and acting like prosecutors during the trial.
The show cause order stemmed from Panelo’s remarks questioning the impartiality of Senators Risa Hontiveros, Francis Pangilinan and Raffy Tulfo during their questioning of former Anti-Money Laundering Council official Rainer Dela Fuente, a defense witness.
Sen. Erwin Tulfo raised the issue at the start of Friday’s proceedings, questioning why Panelo, as the vice president’s spokesman, was publicly attacking members of the impeachment court while Duterte was on trial.
“Your spokesperson of the vice president now on trial here, and then you will comment against the senator-judges, the impeachment court,” Tulfo said, arguing that Panelo’s statements showed disrespect toward the tribunal.
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis Escudero said Panelo was not directly covered by the court’s sub judice rule because he was neither a lawyer of record, a witness nor a party to the proceedings.
However, Escudero said the court could exercise authority over Panelo under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court, which governs contempt proceedings and applies suppletorily to the impeachment trial.
Tulfo then moved to issue a show cause order requiring Panelo to explain his remarks. Escudero approved the motion without objection and directed the clerk of court to issue the order.
The directive gives Panelo an opportunity to explain his statements and does not constitute a finding of contempt.
Panelo had accused Hontiveros, Pangilinan and Tulfo of displaying bias in their questioning of Dela Fuente, arguing that challenging a witness’ credibility was the prosecution’s responsibility.
His position also differed from that of defense panel spokesman Michael Poa, who said Thursday that senator-judges were entitled to ask questions and express their views during the proceedings.
The controversy unfolded as the defense continued presenting evidence against allegations of at least P817.87 million in unexplained wealth attributed to Duterte under Article II of the impeachment complaint.




