
MANILA, Philippines — A defense witness faced intense questioning from senator-judges on Thursday after admitting he had never seen the prosecution’s 50-page forensic report on Vice President Sara Duterte’s alleged unexplained wealth, which he was called to address during her impeachment trial.
Lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente told the Senate impeachment court on Day 44 of the proceedings that he had not received a copy of the report prepared by prosecution witness and financial forensic analyst Alexander Cabrera or other documents presented by the prosecution.
He also admitted that he had not read the documents before taking the witness stand.
Senator-judge Joel Villanueva questioned how Dela Fuente could challenge Cabrera’s findings without first reviewing the report, stressing that determining whether the findings were incorrect was ultimately a matter for the court.
Defense counsel Mark Vinluan explained that the defense wanted to present the documents in open court and had opted not to provide them to the subpoenaed witness beforehand.
Vinluan said the defense intended to focus on selected portions of the forensic report and discuss specific concepts rather than go through the entire document.
Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo, however, questioned how Dela Fuente could contradict the forensic expert’s findings without knowing what was contained in the report.
“If he is going to refute the forensic expert witness without even being given a copy of the documents presented by that expert, then he should not be allowed to contradict or challenge the findings. In the first place, he has no idea what the witness actually said or what the documents contain,” Tulfo said.
Dela Fuente maintained that he did not need to examine Cabrera’s specific forensic financial report to determine whether its findings were consistent with the provisions of the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA).
Tulfo also questioned Dela Fuente’s qualifications to address such a wide range of legal and institutional matters.
He suggested that the defense had placed excessive expectations on its witness.
“Maybe it’s not your fault, and I’m not going to blame you for this. Perhaps the problem is with the defense. They have so much confidence in you, but they may be expecting more from you than you can actually deliver or answer,” Tulfo said.
He added that the defense was making Dela Fuente appear as though he knew everything, even when he might not be able to substantiate his answers.
Tulfo also questioned the relevance of presenting Dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) official, arguing that his testimony on money laundering was unnecessary because the issue was not included in the Articles of Impeachment against Duterte.
He further pointed out that the Senate impeachment court was exempt from certain bank confidentiality restrictions, including disclosure limitations under AMLA.
For Tulfo, these exemptions meant the court did not need Dela Fuente’s testimony to obtain relevant bank account information.
Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo, meanwhile, urged Duterte’s defense team to present more qualified and prepared witnesses, questioning the value of testimony based largely on theory rather than actual financial records.
He pointed out that Dela Fuente had not examined suspicious transaction reports (STRs), covered transaction reports (CTRs), or other financial intelligence documents that could support or contradict the prosecution’s findings.
“What is the value of his expertise if he has not even seen the documents? What is he going to testify about when everything is based on theory and his personal belief?” Erwin Tulfo asked.
He said Dela Fuente’s previous experience with the AMLC was not enough to substantiate his testimony without examining the actual records.
The senator urged the defense to present witnesses who could directly address and rebut the prosecution’s evidence.
“I know the defense can do better than this. In the coming days, perhaps you should bring in a witness who can really stand their ground,” he said.
“I cannot dictate whom you should present, but I am just giving my opinion. The witnesses you have presented over the past few days have been somewhat weak,” he added.
He called on the defense to bring in more competent and professional witnesses who could effectively challenge the prosecution’s claims and answer questions from the senator-judges.
“Bring someone who is truly professional, someone who can rebut what the prosecution has presented and can answer the questions,” he said.




