
Dewan Rakyat in uproar over Deputy Speaker’s decision to join debate
KUALA LUMPUR: An unusual move by Deputy Speaker Datuk Seri Ramli Mohd Nor to leave the Speaker’s chair and join the Budget 2027 debate as an MP triggered a heated procedural dispute in the Dewan Rakyat today.
The controversy erupted when Ramli, who was presiding over the sitting, announced that he would participate in the committee-stage debate on the Works Ministry’s allocation in his capacity as the MP for Cameron Highlands.
READ MORE: Selangor Speaker to verify assemblyman’s eligibility status
READ MORE: Speaker urges MPs to undergo regular health screenings
He subsequently stepped down from the Speaker’s dais and took his place among MPs to question the postponement of several road projects, leaving the chair temporarily vacant.
The move immediately drew objections from Datuk Seri Dr Ronald Kiandee (PN-Beluran), a former Deputy Speaker, who questioned who was overseeing proceedings while Ramli participated in the debate.
Ronald argued that a temporary presiding officer should have been appointed before Ramli left the chair, insisting that the position could not be left vacant during parliamentary proceedings.
“The Speaker guides the House, meaning somebody has to be there. It is convention,” he said, describing the situation as unprecedented.
Ramli, however, defended his decision, saying he had checked the Standing Orders and found no provision prohibiting him from speaking from his seat as an MP.
“I am also the Speaker, and I have chosen to speak from my seat. I have checked, and that does not go against any rules. I will return to my seat and preside as Deputy Speaker after debating,” he said.
Speaking as an MP, Ramli questioned why letters of acceptance for several road projects had been deferred, including two in Pahang.
The projects involved the 34km Pos Sendrut-Lipis road, estimated to cost RM320 million, and a RM90 million road linking Pos Selenjang to Pos Itom.
“What I want to know is who gave this instruction and what is the reason,” he said, adding that most of the affected projects were located in Barisan Nasional and Perikatan Nasional constituencies.
Following the exchange, Deputy Speaker Alice Lau took over the chair, allowing Ramli to return to his seat on the dais.
However, the controversy continued when Datuk Ngeh Koo Ham (PH-Beruas) raised a point of order, strongly objecting to Ramli’s move and warning that the incident could undermine Parliament’s standing.
“I wish to record my sadness and my objection so that this Parliament will not become a mockery and a laughing stock, not only in Malaysia but around the world,” he said.
Ngeh argued that parliamentary proceedings must always be presided over by a Speaker or chairman to ensure that the rules were observed. He questioned how Ramli could participate in a debate while also overseeing proceedings.
He also called for the episode to be expunged from the Hansard.
In response, Ramli invoked Standing Order 99, which gives the Speaker or Deputy Speaker the authority to interpret the Standing Orders and make rulings on procedural matters.
He maintained that the Standing Orders did not specifically prohibit a presiding officer from speaking from another seat in the House, adding that MPs who disagreed with his interpretation could move a motion.
Ngeh, however, hit back, arguing that Standing Order 99 “does not allow us to have a dictator as Speaker or Deputy Speaker in this Dewan”.
The remark prompted Kurniawan Naim Moktar (BN-Kinabatangan) to invoke Standing Order 36(6), which concerns imputations of improper motives, and call on Ngeh to withdraw the word “dictator”.
Ramli subsequently said he would not pursue the matter further, reiterating that his decision to move seats did not amount to abandoning his responsibilities as Deputy Speaker.
“What happened just now still does not invalidate or mean I abdicated as chairman during the period I chaired the sitting,” he said before proceedings resumed.





