Elected in 2025, staying until 2028

WorldPolitics
11 Nov 2026 • 12:06 AM MYT
The Manila Times
The Manila Times

One of the longest-running English broadsheets in the Philippines

Elected in 2025, staying until 2028

IN October 2023, Filipinos lined up at their schools and barangay (village) halls to choose their kapitan (captain or chairman) and kagawad (councilors), as well as their Sangguniang Kabataan (SK or youth council) officials. They were told the next chance to choose again would come in December 2025.

It did not come. Congress moved the vote to November 2026. Then last September, it moved it again to November 2028. On Oct. 14, the Supreme Court, voting 9–5, said this latest move was allowed under the Constitution

That decision must be respected. The Supreme Court has the final say on what the Constitution means, and a country that ignores its courts soon stops being a country of laws. The 2028 elections will happen under the rules the high court has now approved.

But respecting a decision does not mean pretending there was nothing to disagree with. Five of the 14 justices who voted did not fully agree with the majority. What they said is worth hearing because it is about something every voter understands.

Think of it this way: A household hires a caretaker on a contract that ends in December 2025. Before the contract expires, the household is told that caretakers will now serve longer, and that the current one will simply stay on until 2028. The household never agreed to that. It hired someone until 2025 and expected to decide again when the contract was up.

That, in simple terms, is the point raised by Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen and the two justices who joined him. Nobody questions that Congress can decide how long barangay officials serve. Five years may even be a good idea. The problem is applying the longer term to officials who were elected for a shorter one. The extra years, Justice Leonen wrote, are held “by the statute alone.” In other words, the law, not the voter, gave those officials the extra time.

The Constitution already follows this rule elsewhere. Congress cannot add even one day to the terms of members of the Senate and the House of Representatives. When lawmakers raise their own salaries, the raise goes only to whoever comes after them. The idea behind both rules is fairness: whoever holds power should not be the one who benefits from changing the rules. Justice Leonen asked why barangay officials should be treated differently. The majority did not really answer.

Then there is the matter of how often this has happened. Since 1998, the barangay elections have been postponed or reset eight times, six of them in just the last 10 years. The last law setting a four-year term was passed only 13 months before this one. Not a single barangay official ever served under that four-year term. Justice Alfredo Benjamin Caguioa warned that when postponements keep getting approved, the Constitution’s protections start to become mere formalities. Each delay may look reasonable on its own. But put together, they add up to years of voters waiting.

Young people pay the steepest price. Only Filipinos aged 15 to 30 can vote in SK elections, and only those 18 to 24 can run. A 30-year-old who could have voted this year will be too old by 2028. A 24-year-old who planned to run for SK chairman has lost that chance for good. For them, the vote was not delayed; it was taken away. The Supreme Court said any harm could be fixed later by holding elections. For these young Filipinos, nothing later can fix it.

Justice Antonio Kho Jr. pointed out that there was a simpler way: Congress could have kept the November 2026 elections and given the five-year term to whoever won. Several senators and House representatives proposed exactly that. The country would have gotten the longer term it wanted, and voters would have kept the election they were promised. Congress chose otherwise, and the majority said Congress did not have to pick the gentler option.

Some of the reasons given also do not quite add up. Lawmakers said they wanted to keep the barangay elections from falling in the same year as national elections, so they avoided 2031. Yet the new schedule puts the barangay vote in 2028 — the same year Filipinos will elect a new president. It was also said holding the vote in 2027 would burden the Commission on Elections as it prepares for 2028. It was never explained why holding it six months after the 2028 national elections would be any easier.

None of these changes the outcome. The law stands, and the November 2028 elections deserve the full support of every Filipino so they are orderly, peaceful and credible.

But there is a lesson here, and a way forward that does not need another court case. Congress can pass a one-sentence rule: whenever the term of barangay or SK officials is changed, the change applies only to those elected afterward. Congress gives up nothing. It can still make the term five years, or any length it wants. The new term simply starts with the next election, not the last one.

Congress may set the term; only voters can grant the mandate. A country that respects both can give its barangay officials longer terms without asking its citizens to give up their vote.

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved