
KUALA LUMPUR: A prospective candidate for the Fifa presidency has demanded an urgent ruling on whether Gianni Infantino is eligible to stand for another term, calling for Wednesday’s nomination deadline to be suspended until the dispute is resolved.
Peter Auf der Heyde, a South African-German journalist, author and university lecturer, wants the world football governing body’s own rules applied equally to everyone.
In a statement to Twentytwo13, Auf der Heyde said he has written to Fifa’s Governance, Audit and Compliance Committee requesting a reasoned decision on Mr Infantino’s eligibility ahead of the 2027 presidential election.
He has also sought legal guidance on the matter and appealed to all 211 member associations to back his call to freeze the Nov 18 cut-off.
Under Article 33(2) of the Fifa Statutes, a president is limited to three terms in office, whether consecutive or not.
Infantino was elected in 2016, 2019 and 2023. However, in December 2022, Fifa adopted an interpretation stating that his initial period in office — from 2016 to 2019 — would not count towards that limit.
That interpretation has previously been questioned by Prof Miguel Poiares Maduro, the former chairman of Fifa’s Governance Committee, and the human rights organisation FairSquare, which wrote to Fifa’s Review Committee in August 2026.
Auf der Heyde is asking Fifa to explain the legal basis for its stance and formally determine whether the incumbent is entitled to run again in 2027. He has requested a substantive response by Monday.
Before contacting Fifa, Auf der Heyde sought legal advice regarding the duties of Fifa’s Review Committee and the possibility of challenging an eligibility decision at the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS).
“Having sought legal guidance, my understanding is that Fifa’s Review Committee has an independent obligation to determine presidential eligibility, regardless of whether anyone formally requests a ruling,” he said.
“This is not simply a question of whether I have standing to challenge Infantino’s eligibility. Fifa has its own responsibility to establish whether someone seeking the presidency meets the requirements of its statutes.”
He has also explored whether a prospective candidate who has yet to secure the five required member association nominations could bring a challenge before CAS.
“One argument is that allowing an incumbent whose eligibility is disputed to participate in the election process could itself make it more difficult for a challenger to obtain the required nominations,” Auf der Heyde said.
“I understand that this is a legally arguable position. I am continuing to seek specialist advice on that question.”
He stressed that Fifa’s Review Committee has an independent responsibility to rule on eligibility regardless of whether he, or anyone else, has legal standing at CAS.
Should Fifa rule that Infantino is eligible, Auf der Heyde wants sufficient time to pursue any available legal remedies before nominations close.
“Fifa should not allow the nomination deadline to expire while there is an unresolved question about whether the incumbent is entitled to stand,” he said.
“If Fifa rules that Infantino is eligible, I want the opportunity to have that interpretation independently examined, provided the applicable rules allow such a challenge.”
Auf der Heyde rejected any suggestion that his intervention was motivated by doubts over his own prospects of securing the five nominations needed to get on the ballot.
“This is not about sour grapes. I knew from the outset that securing five nominations would be extremely difficult, particularly when challenging an incumbent Fifa president,” he said.
“But that is not why I am raising this issue. This is about transparency, democracy and accountability. Fifa introduced presidential term limits for a reason. Those limits must apply equally to everyone.
“No president should be able to benefit from an interpretation of the rules that is not properly explained and open to scrutiny.”
Auf der Heyde, whose career in football spans almost five decades as a player, administrator, club manager, journalist and academic, is campaigning under the banner Every Nation Matters.
His proposals include creating an Emerging Nations World Cup, establishing an independent Football Advisory Council, increasing investment in women’s football and accepting a salary of just US$1 a year unless independently assessed campaign promises are fulfilled.
Despite his campaign, he insists becoming Fifa president has never been his primary goal.
“I entered this campaign because I believed that Infantino needed to be challenged and that Fifa should not have an uncontested presidential election,” he said.
“If a more suitable candidate comes forward who is prepared to challenge Infantino and offer football a genuine alternative, I will not seek election. Equally, if Infantino is ruled ineligible, I will withdraw my candidacy.”
He added that Fifa belongs to its member associations rather than its president, warning that those associations share a collective responsibility to ensure the body is governed transparently.
“The question is not whether I become president,” he said.
“The question is whether Fifa respects the rules it introduced to prevent the concentration of power.”



