Harry Potter fans condemn ‘ugly’ and ‘whimsyless’ first TV clip: ‘Literally what is going on?’

EntertainmentMovie
16 Nov 2026 • 7:26 PM MYT
The Independent
The Independent

The world’s most free-thinking newspaper

Harry Potter fans condemn ‘ugly’ and ‘whimsyless’ first TV clip: ‘Literally what is going on?’

The first clip from the forthcoming Harry Potter TV show has prompted a wave of disparaging reactions from fans – including complaints over the lighting, set design, and pacing.

Harry Potter, premiering on HBO Max this Christmas, is the second major screen adaptation of JK Rowling’s bestselling children’s books, after the hit film series released between 2001 and 2011.

The first series will cover the events of the first Harry Potter book, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, which was previously adapted for the screen by Christopher Columbus.

While the series has attracted significant backlash – and a boycott – over Rowling’s views on transgender rights, the first clip from HBO’s Harry Potter has drawn extensive criticism on aesthetic merits alone.

On social media, many people criticised the lighting and visuals in the clip, which shows Hogwarts students attending a banquet with the school’s headmaster, Albus Dumbledore (John Lithgow).

“The characters literally look like cosplay,” one person wrote. “There is no sense of magic. Everything is dimly lit and depressing and it does not spark joy. An AI Malfoid edit has 100x more passion. This is whimsyless.”

“Oh it’s so ugly,” wrote another. “Comically flat. We’re just allergic to contrast I guess.”

“Harry Potter and the raw camera data,” someone else quipped. “I like the random b-roll of the kids eating for like 10 unbroken seconds. literally what is going on.”

“Why does this look like AI???” another person asked. “It’s so clean, doesn’t even look real, it looks like a skit or a parody of Harry Potter wtf.”

One social media user simply put: “Harry Potter and the chamber of low contrast.”

Janet McTeer and John Lithgow in 'Harry Potter' (HBO)

Several people likened the footage to a TV advertisement, with one person joking that it was “like a Superbowl ad for Progressive auto insurance”.

“All the magic and whimsy of an insurance commercial,” wrote another.

“At any point in this any of the characters could have turned to camera holding a chicken wing and said ‘KFC. It's finger-lickin’ good.’ and I wouldn't have batted an eye,” someone else joked.

Others also compared the film negatively to the 2001 adaptation.

Among the differences highlighted were the in-scene lighting, with Columbus’s film featuring a multitude of ornate candles – as described in the source material – while the new TV adaptation features muted table lamps.

“Jesus christ, really gives you an appreciation for the directing talents of *checks notes* Chris Columbus,” one X user wrote.

“There is *profound* sense of ‘why are we doing this’ that permeates every frame,” another remarked.

Alongside Lithgow, Harry Potter stars actors including Paapa Essiedu, Bel Powley, Warwick Davis, Janet McTeer, and Nick Frost. The three child leads will be portrayed by newcomers Dominic McLaughlin, Alastair Stout and Arabella Stanton.

Rowling, 61, has become an increasingly controversial figure in recent years thanks to her public statements on issues surrounding trans rights.

The children’s author – who has denied that her views are transphobic – has previously claimed she would rather go to jail than refer to trans people by their chosen pronouns, and has donated large sums of money to organisations pushing for legislative change over sex-based rights and single-sex spaces.

Rowling serves as an executive producer on the new series, which will debut on HBO Max on 25 December.

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved