On a calm morning in the South China Sea, clear blue water reflects the sun's rays. Divers and snorkelers enjoy the underwater beauty of Redang Island, hoping to encounter colorful corals and exotic marine life. But suddenly the peaceful atmosphere broke into a violent scene: a turtle struggling to rise to the surface was squeezed, pressed, and even occupied by its shell. The scene appeared in a viral video for about 20 seconds, which spread quickly on social media and sparked national and international outrage.
What appeared to be a "near-nature tour" turned into a scene of atrocities that embarrassed the image of Malaysia's marine conservation. It's no longer just an ethical violation, it's a violation of the law that shows how fragile nature protection is in the face of the tourism industry, regulatory neglect, and lack of human empathy.
In a report by the South China Morning Post, the video showed a diver "repeatedly holding a turtle by its shell and neck while snorkeling" in the waters of Redang Island, Terengganu. Some people seemed to surround the turtles, dampening them from coming to the surface. In one sad moment, a man is seen standing on top of a turtle's shell, while the creature attempts to swim away from human pressure. (South China Morning Post)
Borneo's Tropical Conservation Research and Conservation Centre (TRACC) called for strong condemnation of the action, calling it "deeply disturbing and concerning." They warn that even though turtles can hold their breath for a long time, they still must surface to breathe if prevented, which could lead to death like other aerial creatures. (South China Morning Post)
News reports such as The Scuba News also confirm that the act of capturing, restraint, or preventing turtles from coming to the surface is an unjustified form of marine abuse. (The Scuba News)
As soon as the video spread, netizens flooded the comment column with criticism. Many have denounced the perpetrator's actions as a form of greed for misguided "Instagram content" or "extreme experiences". Some users reshared the video as a warning but also debated the ethics of spreading violent scenes for public consumption.
Local media Daily Express, Facebook and Instagram also highlighted the incident, saying that the turtles were suppressed, touched, and prevented from their freedom by humans. (Facebook)
In Malaysia, turtles are protected animals. Based on the Fisheries Act 1985, Section 27 expressly prohibits anyone from catching, harassing, handling, or "disturbing" turtles unless there is an official permit. (Sinar Daily)
The Terengganu government immediately ordered an investigation after the viral video The state Tourism, Culture & Digital Technology Committee chairman, Ariffin Deraman, stressed that actions such as the video were an offence and should not be allowed. (Sinar Daily)
But the challenge is great: the law without supervision is no different from an empty word. Many beaches and popular marine zones are difficult to reach for routine patrols, and resources for surveillance (patrol boats, marine officers, sensors) are often limited.
This is also not the first time such incidents in Terengganu. In 2022, a viral video showed a person holding a turtle on Redang Island and the state government at the time ordered the Department of Marine Parks to investigate. (Sinar Daily)
Despite public pressure and warrants for an investigation, the perpetrators are rarely publicly revealed, and the deterrent effect appears weak. This reflects the loopholes in law enforcement and a lack of transparency in dealing with threats to nature.
Malaysia's marine tourism continues to grow snorkeling, diving, "direct interaction" experiences with marine life are selling points. But the desire for "touch & feel" often exceeds the boundaries of responsibility. Undisciplined tour operators sometimes encourage customers to "reach for turtles" for the sake of a tourist experience, without considering the ecological impact.
TRACC called the act "tourism malpractice," a tourism approach that places living things as objects of entertainment, not valued subjects. (South China Morning Post)
The average traveler doesn't understand that touching turtles, restraining them, or obstructing their breathing is a danger. Many judge that "one touch is okay," even though one small action can trigger stress, infection, or death.
The lack of information boards, local education before snorkeling, and guidance supervision make nature interactions often allowed to happen as they please.
The marine patrol system, coastal surveillance, and the ability to identify perpetrators are still vulnerable. Even if there is a video, law enforcement must verify: the time, location, identity of the perpetrator. Otherwise, the case could stagnate.
Resources, funds, and coordination between marine institutions and state tourism are obstacles. Without real enforcement powers, threats continue to emerge.
Every sea turtle is part of a fragile marine ecosystem. Abusive interactions, repetitive stress, or disturbances during spawning can trigger the domino effect:
- Disturbed turtles may stop spawning on those beaches, reducing the population in the future.
- Human touch can damage the skin's protective layer or introduce foreign bacteria.
- If prevented from appearing on the surface of the air, the turtle can deprive them of oxygen and drown even though it seems to be able to hold its breath for a long time.
- Declines in turtle populations degrade ecological functions: they help maintain the health of seaweed, control jellyfish populations, and nourish coral reef ecosystems.
In the context of Terengganu, Redang and the surrounding beaches have been important areas for turtle habitat, incidents like this can trigger migration or decline in the local population.
- Identify the perpetrator through videos and social media evidence, then impose sanctions based on the Fisheries Act.
- Publish your name or identity (if permitted by law) for a deterrent effect.
- Increase marine patrols in turtle spawning season, especially in popular snorkeling zones.
Ethical Sea Tourism Certification
- The application of a snorkeling/diving license guide that requires the operator to understand the guidelines for natural interaction (no touching, no disturbing).
- Mandatory training for local guides and tour operators on marine conservation ethics.
Education & Awareness Campaigns
- Install a sign prohibiting touching turtles at the snorkel and beach points.
- Before the sea tour, the guide should give a briefing: "What to do and what not to do."
- Involve local schools, fishing communities, and tourists in the ocean rescue campaign.
Technology & Monitoring System
- Use marine drones, underwater cameras, and location sensors to monitor snorkeling activities in sensitive zones.
- Community reporting system application for reporting if there is a disturbance of turtles or marine animals.
- Visual and GPS databases to track videos/videos of violations spread on social media.
The 20-second video is what inserts the screams of a turtle creature that cannot make a sound in front of a crowd of humans. When the human hand squeezes, the world witnesses that the progress of tourism sometimes brings harm to nature.
Not angry enough, not viral enough. Real action is what we need: law enforcement, public education, ethical tourism regulations. So that in Malaysia's beautiful islands, the sea is not only our backdrop, but the home we must protect.
Hopefully this incident will be a turning point and not just a momentary anger so that in the future every snorkeling will be a peaceful experience, not a scene of violence that is immortalized. The blue sea and turtles will continue to breathe, if humans are willing to act with conscience and conscience.
AM World (tameer.work88@gmail.com) is a content creator under the Newswav Creator programme, where you get to express yourself, be a citizen journalist, and at the same time monetize your content & reach millions of users on Newswav. Log in to creator.newswav.com and become a Newswav Creator now!
The User Content (as defined on Newswav Terms of Use) above including the views expressed and media (pictures, videos, citations etc) were submitted & posted by the author. Newswav is solely an aggregation platform that hosts the User Content. If you have any questions about the content, copyright or other issues of the work, please contact creator@newswav.com.