Whether enjoying a frothy glass of teh tarik at a local mamak stall or cooling down with a bowl of Ais Kacang (ABC) under the afternoon sun, canned milk products are staples of Malaysian food culture. Known for imparting a rich, creamy texture and distinct sweetness, these canned additions are widely regarded as traditional dairy components. However, beneath the familiar tins and nostalgic branding lies a critical food-labeling reality that surprises many consumers: the majority of canned products labeled as "susu pekat" (condensed milk) or "susu cair" (evaporated milk) sold in commercial eateries are not 100% pure dairy milk at all. Instead, most commercial vendors rely on sweetened creamers (krimer manis) and evaporated creamers (krimer sejat), where natural dairy fats are replaced with vegetable oils and added sugars. Examining the ingredient science behind these products helps clarify what you are actually consuming and how it impacts your long-term health.
Ingredient Science: Are They "Real Milk" or Non-Dairy Alternatives?
To evaluate whether these ingredients qualify as real dairy milk, one must examine food regulation standards set by the Ministry of Health Malaysia (MOH) and standard commercial manufacturing processes.
1. "Susu Pekat Manis" vs. "Krimer Manis" (Used in Teh Tarik & ABC)
- Real Sweetened Condensed Milk (Susu Pekat Manis): Authentic condensed milk is produced by evaporating water from whole cow's milk and adding sugar as a natural preservative. It retains natural milk proteins, calcium, and dairy fats.
Commercial Creamers (Krimer Manis / Sweetened Creamer): Most low-cost tins sold in markets or used in mamak stalls contain minimal milk solids. The primary ingredient listed on the label is typically refined sugar, followed by palm oil/vegetable fat, water, whey powder, and chemical emulsifiers. Therefore, krimer manis is essentially an emulsified mixture of sugar and vegetable oil rather than pure dairy.
2. "Susu Cair" vs. "Krimer Sejat" (Used on ABC & Coffee)
- Real Evaporated Milk (Susu Sejat): Made by heating fresh milk to remove roughly 60% of its water content, resulting in a concentrated, unsweetened liquid rich in milk nutrients.
- Evaporated Creamer / Filled Milk (Krimer Sejat / Susu Isian Sejat): The milk fat is extracted and replaced with refined palm olein to reduce manufacturing costs. While it provides a rich pour over shaving ice in ABC, it functions biologically as an emulsified vegetable oil liquid rather than pure animal dairy.
From a clinical and public health perspective, frequent consumption of commercial sweetened and evaporated creamers presents several nutritional challenges:
1. Excessive Refined Sugar Load
A single standard mug of teh tarik prepared with krimer manis contains approximately 26 grams of added sugar (or ~4.5 teaspoons) meeting or exceeding the World Health Organization’s recommended daily sugar intake limit in just one serving. In shaved-ice desserts like ABC, where krimer manis, krimer sejat, and flavored syrups are combined, the glycemic load spikes rapidly, contributing to blood glucose instability.
2. Caloric Density and Visceral Fat Gain
The combination of refined sugars and processed palm fats creates a hyper-palatable, calorie-dense ingredient. Regular intake without physical exertion increases the risk of weight gain, elevated visceral fat, and metabolic syndrome.
3. Low Micronutrient Yield
Unlike whole fresh milk or fortified pasteurized dairy, commercial creamers offer minimal calcium, magnesium, or complete proteins relative to their high calorie count.
Product Comparison Table
| Product Category | Primary First Ingredient | Dairy Fat Content | Typical Usage | Health Impact Level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fresh / Full Cream Milk | Fresh Cow's Milk | 100% Natural Dairy Fat | Daily drinking, cereal | High Nutritional Value |
| Real Evaporated Milk | Concentrated Cow's Milk | Natural Dairy Fat | Cooking, gourmet tea/coffee | Moderate (Calorie Dense) |
| Sweetened Creamer (Krimer Manis) | Refined Sugar | Replaced with Palm Oil | Local Teh Tarik, Kopi | High Sugar/Fat Warning |
| Evaporated Creamer (Krimer Sejat) | Water / Milk Solids / Palm Oil | Replaced with Palm Oil | Topping for ABC, Hong Kong Toast | Moderate-to-High Caloric Load |
Verifiable Scientific References & Hyperlinked Sources
Malaysian Food Regulations 1985 (P.U.(A) 437/85 - Standards for Milk & Creamers):
Regulation & Standard: Under Regulations 95, 97, 98, and 99 of the Malaysian Food Regulations 1985 (P.U.(A) 437/85), products where natural milk fat is substituted with edible vegetable fats (such as palm oil) are legally designated as "Condensed Filled Milk" or "Sweetened Creamer" (Krimer Manis), explicitly separating them from 100% pure dairy milk.
World Health Organization (WHO) Guidelines on Sugar Intake:
Evidence: According to the official WHO Guideline on Sugars Intake for Adults and Children, daily intake of free sugars should be reduced to less than 10% of total energy intake, with a further reduction to below 5% (~25 grams per day) providing additional health benefits. A single serving of commercial teh tarik prepared with sweetened creamer delivers around 26 grams of sugar, exceeding this daily threshold in one cup.
- Study: Research published on Sweetened Condensed Creamers Formulations by Lactalis Ingredients highlights that commercial sweetened creamers feature significantly reduced milk protein concentrations (~1.5% to 3%) compared to authentic sweetened condensed milk (~7.5% protein), relying on vegetable oil emulsification and texturizers to replicate dairy viscosity.
How to Enjoy Your Treats Healthier
You do not need to give up local favorites entirely to maintain a healthy lifestyle. Here are practical adjustments you can make:
- Order "Teh Tarik Kurang Manis" or "Teh C Kosong": Requesting "Teh C" replaces sweetened creamer with unsweetened evaporated milk, drastically reducing added sugar.
- Check the Tin Label at Home: When shopping for home cooking or baking, look for products labeled "Susu Sejat" or "Susu Pekat Manis" rather than "Krimer". Check the ingredient list to ensure milk solids or milk appear before added sugar and palm oil.
- Control ABC Syrup Portions: When enjoying ABC, ask the vendor to reduce the condensed creamer drizzle and flavored syrups, allowing you to enjoy the crushed ice, red beans, and grass jelly with a lower sugar load.
What Do You Think? I’d Love to Hear Your Opinion in The Comments Section.
While the "susu pekat" and "susu cair" used in everyday teh tarik and ABC provide iconic local flavors, most commercial varieties are sweetened or evaporated creamers made from sugar and vegetable oils rather than pure dairy milk. Because of their high sugar and caloric density, they are best enjoyed as occasional treats rather than daily nutritional staples. Making informed choices about ingredients allows you to celebrate Malaysia's rich food culture while protecting your long-term health.
Share your fitness and healthy lifestyle stories through #JomFit and stand a chance to win cash prizes worth up to RM2,300!
Find out how to join here. Don't miss out! T&Cs apply.
AM World (tameer.work88@gmail.com) is a content creator under the Newswav Creator programme, where you get to express yourself, be a citizen journalist, and at the same time monetize your content & reach millions of users on Newswav. Log in to creator.newswav.com and become a Newswav Creator now!
The User Content (as defined on Newswav Terms of Use) above including the views expressed and media (pictures, videos, citations etc) were submitted & posted by the author. Newswav is solely an aggregation platform that hosts the User Content. If you have any questions about the content, copyright or other issues of the work, please contact creator@newswav.com.
