Benoit Blanc vs Sherlock Holmes: Benoit Blanc is to murder mysteries what a majority of people would be to a spa. He is serene, takes his time, and is more elegantly dressed than the circumstances would suggest. Sherlock Holmes on the other hand is like a very efficient and quick tactical lightning strike of pure intellect. And he leaves cigarette ash in his weak. Holmes is London fog. Blanc is a poolside Negroni. As Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery is nearly here, let’s find out why Benoit Blanc is sort of an anti-Sherlock. This is not a straight up Benoit Blanc from Knives Out movies vs Sherlock Holmes from well… too many movies and shows to count.
For decades, the detective and murder mystery genre has been handcuffed to the Holmes model (well, Holmes and Hercule Poirot, but mostly Holmes). You know, the irritable genius who treats people like case files. Then Rian Johnson introduced a detective who refuses to weaponise intelligence. Blanc listens. He sympathises. He even meanders. And somehow, he ends up untangling human condition through emotional geometry. This is in stark contrast to Sherlock’s use of intellect and cold deduction.
This move to Blanc (played brilliantly by former James Bond Daniel Craig) seems like it was made specifically for the current situation. We are dealing with a lot of prestige detectives who handle trauma with a perpetual scowl. Blanc is the cure. He is a detective who hydrates. He takes his time. He sees good manners as a way of moral clarity. He goes after the bad guys without setting the whole place on fire.
Why Benoit Blanc is the anti-Sherlock we didn’t know we needed
Benoit Blanc vs Sherlock Holmes: Sherlock Holmes is the foundation stone of modern detective fiction, no denying that. And admittedly, he is one of this scribe’s favourite literary characters. But he is also its most inflexible template. His near-mystical powers of deduction are accompanied by a total disregard for social niceties and a bristling contempt for anyone slower than him. Which is pretty much everyone.
Emotional austerity is part of his identity, a fact that bothers his only true friend and confidante Dr. John H. Watson. The world is a puzzle. And people are merely pieces waiting to be rearranged. The character has been portrayed by iconic actors Basil Rathbone and Jeremy Brett in the olden days and Robert Downey Jr. and Benedict Cumberbatch in the 21st century.
Even current reimaginings still mostly uphold the original myth of a genius figure living isolated, his intellect leading to alienation. His prodigy is a burden he has to bear. Popular culture has long glorified the idea that smartest person in the room will always be lonely, annoyed, and depressed. Sherlock is operative and over the top. It seems as though he is about to break down mentally all the time. For more than a century, audiences accepted that this was the cost of intelligence.
However, I must add that Sherlock may pretend to be aloof, but he does have an emotional side to him that Watson is privy to. He does express muted happiness, for instance, when Watson is impressed by his genius deductions. Oh, and he does love solving crimes and wouldn’t rest until he knows who the culprit is and he has enough evidence against him.
Blanc’s rebellion: A detective who enjoys being alive
Benoit Blanc vs Sherlock Holmes: Benoit Blanc is the one who comes to take apart the Sherlockian doctrine. In fact, he is a detective who genuinely likes people. Sherlock despises interactions and relies totally on his observations. Blanc sees them as the instrument of his investigation.
What sets Craig’s detective apart is not charm for its own sake but charm as strategy. He disarms. He engages. He also makes others comfortable enough to reveal themselves without even realising it. His process is not built on intimidation but on invitation. He draws humanity out instead of slicing it apart. This is genre where detectives often solve crimes by cutting away feelings. Blanc solves them by paying attention to what those feelings signify.
In the original Knives Out, we see Benoit Blanc really understands and shares the feelings of Marta Cabrera (Ana de Armas), a nurse who becomes the emotional centre. He doesn’t use her as a disposable witness. Instead Blanc sees her ethical purity even before he realises the whole extent of the crime and the surrounding circumstances.
He realises that she is uncomfortable and dejected about the death of Harlan Thrombey. So he changes his tempo to her silences. It is as though he instinctually feels that her kindness is not a front. In a detective movie like this, the crime-solver would normally exploit the vulnerability. But, Blanc instead sees it as one of her genuine traits. Their relationship is the most obvious indication that he gets to know the people before he gets to know their motives.
So who wins in Benoit Blanc vs Sherlock Holmes in the end? Well, Sherlock was the blueprint, but Blanc is the detective we need today. So, it’s a draw.
Loading Poll..(Hero and Featured images: Courtesy of John Wilson/Netflix/IMDb)
Note : The information in this article is accurate as of the date of publication.