Not with the promised ‘bloodbath,’ but with a whimper

WorldPolitics
15 Nov 2026 • 12:09 AM MYT
The Manila Times
The Manila Times

One of the longest-running English broadsheets in the Philippines

Not with the promised ‘bloodbath,’ but with a whimper

BEFORE the defense team of Vice President Sara Duterte even managed to present an opening salvo worthy of a Wagnerian high drama and steeped in constitutional rigor, came the ominous signs that the team that promised to turn the Senate impeachment trial into a "bloodbath" has assembled a cast of either missing, dissembling and bumbling witnesses for the defense.

Law professor Ralph Sarmiento backed out of testifying for the defense at the last minute, citing the need to preserve "the independence of my law scholarship" and "the impartiality of my legal opinions and views." Were there other intervening events and factors that made him decide to back out from an earlier commitment to testify for the defense, other than the need to "preserve my law scholarship?" That we don't know, but that decision naturally raised serious questions. Did he realize that the defense of the Duterte princeling stands on tenuous constitutional grounds?

Or did Sarmiento, former dean of the University of Saint La Salle College of Law in Bacolod, deliberately avoid a legal tangle with Jose Manuel "Chel" Diokno, former dean of De La Salle University College of Law and a member of the House prosecution panel?

With Sarmiento as the first witness, the defense could have laid out a coherent legal thesis on why the impeachment trial was a kangaroo affair in the first place: constitutionally infirm, legally indefensible and 100-percent resting on flawed, dubious assumptions. Demolishing the rationale for the impeachment trial would have been and could have been a very fitting start for the defense.

Deal with the big issue first — the constitutionality — then with the particulars later. The big constitutional picture is the first line of defense. A soaring oratory from Sarmiento, like the one delivered by Clarence Darrow during the famed Scopes Trial, could have demolished the constitutional argument for impeaching Duterte.

But the demolition of the constitutional ground for impeachment by a constitutional expert never came, and the first witness to swear under oath for the Duterte defense was, of all people, Jaime Adalin, Davao City’s assessor. The senator-judges cast doubt on Adalin’s credibility after he admitted under oath that he took foreign trips, the latest of which was a December 2025 trip to China, but was clueless on the trips’ details. The city assessor claimed to have personally paid for trips in Hong Kong, Australia, and elsewhere but has forgotten about those trips’ particulars altogether. Adalin was called out by the senator-judges for his inconsistent testimonies over a Matina, Davao City property owned by Duterte and her husband Manases “Mans” Carpio.

The seriousness of the people lined up as witnesses for the Duterte princeling suffered another blow with the third witness, Davao City accountant Vingelin Bajan. It turned out Bajan held double jobs from 2004 to 2015: one with the Davao City accounting office and the other with a private accounting firm serving companies mostly in the Davao area. Worse, her private firm — Ampil, Elises, Ciudadano and Co., CPAs — served as external auditor to several companies linked to Duterte and Carpio. Bajan, at one point in her accounting career, served then-mayor Duterte in Davao City’s accounting office and affixed her signature as partner of the accounting firm that did external audits for companies linked to the Carpio couple.

John Kenneth Enumerables, the second witness and the city assessor of the Island Garden City of Samal, barely made a media ripple as he played a cameo role, one that, nonetheless, made him admit before the senator-judges that a Barangay Matanos in the city does not exist. A transfer certificate title covering a 751-square-meter property of Duterte and Carpio said the property was in the nonexistent Matanos. That city’s tax records said the same property of the couple is in Barangay San Isidro. One property in Enumerables’ jurisdiction with two stated locations, which the assessor cannot fully explain. The discrepancy does not end with the location. The deed of sale of the same property stated the price at P3.4 million; the couple’s statement of assets, liabilities and net worth, or SALN, valued the same property at P4.04 million.

Before we all forget, Adalin was the second, not the first, witness in the original list of witnesses. The first was a lawyer named Suzette Balucanag-Punay, who handled corporate matters for two firms linked to Carpio and Duterte: GenCorp Industries and Metro City Chow Foods. On the day (Nov. 9) she was supposed to testify, she had a scheduled ... MRI. Punay took the witness stand on Nov. 10 and admitted that Sara Duterte earned P2.14 million from a “loose investment” in a Jollibee franchise from 2022 to 2025, while that franchise had 19 supply contracts with the Davao City Hall under current Mayor Sebastian Duterte. P2.14 million earnings from a P46,875 investment. Singko tama barko.

Lest we all forget, the Duterte team promised to turn the impeachment process — should it occur — into a “bloodbath.” Witnesses for the Duterte defense that can’t identify their own signatures, can’t recall foreign trip details, dodge many serious questions, and are often stricken with bouts of amnesia, delivered narratives of obfuscation, not “bloodbath” testimonies that will shift the ground for the Duterte princeling.

It is farce and mediocrity altogether, legal slapstick in response to serious constitutional issues raised by the prosecution panel and senator-judges. Thus, forcing many of us who have learned a little poetry in our younger days to riff lines from US poet T.S. Eliot.

This is how the promised “bloodbath” ends. Not with a bang, but with a whimper.

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved