
THE Philippine Competition Commission (PCC) has imposed a P1.76-billion fine on members of a cartel linked to the surge in onion prices in 2022.
The sanctioned firms include Golden Shine International Freight Forwarders Corp., Tian Long Corp., La Reina Fresh Vegetables & Young Indoor Plants, Inc., Yom Trading Corp., and their officials Mark Castro Ocampo, Nancy Callanta Rosal, Lilian Cruz, Eric Pabilona, Renato Francisco Jr. and Letty Baculando.
The fine was so far the largest imposed by the commission on violators. Onions are considered a prime commodity under the Price Act, which explains the 200-percent increase in basic fines.
The importers and their facilitator were ordered to pay the maximum fine of P330 million, while Tian Long and Pabilona were ordered to pay P118.32 million. These were based on turnovers computed by the PCC.
The investigation began after onion prices surged to P800 per kilogram in late 2022. In September 2023, the PCC Enforcement Office conducted a court-ordered raid at the respondents’ offices at the Golden Shine Corporate Center.
In July 2024, the PCC Enforcement Office filed a statement of objections before the commission, charging the involved onion importers and traders with violations of Section 14 of Republic Act 10667, or the Philippine Competition Act.
A PCC investigation revealed that six firms, together with their officials, belonged to an onion cartel engaged in illegal market allocation and importation, storage and wholesale distribution of onions.
PCC Executive Director Kenneth Tanate said Golden Shine applied for sanitary and phytosanitary import clearances using the respondent-importers’ credentials, then assigned them as consignees, monitored permit allocations, and coordinated shipments. With the accumulated permits across different entities, the respondents were able to control nearly 50 percent of all approved import clearances for onions.
Imported shipments were then routed to Tian Long-managed cold storage facilities, from where they were distributed nationwide. The cartel operated in Bulacan, Iloilo City, Cebu City, Cagayan de Oro, and Davao City.
PCC officials said the notice of the decision was communicated to the respondents on Oct. 1, with respondents ordered to pay fines within 15 days of receipt of the decision. This makes Oct. 16, or today (Friday), the deadline for payment of fines.
Tanate said the penalty for noncompliance may range from P60,000 to P2.5 million. There is also a penalty of P55,000 for every day of delay in paying fines.
Filing a motion for reconsideration can be done within 15 days of receipt of the notice.
Agriculture Secretary Francisco Tiu Laurel Jr. said that the firms will be blacklisted if they are still operating.
The PCC said it may also file a criminal complaint before the Department of Justice against the respondents.
Meanwhile, charges against the Philippine Vieva Group of Companies Inc. and the Vegetable Importers, Exporters & Vendors Association of the Philippines Inc. were dismissed due to insufficient evidence of their participation in the market allocation agreement. However, their officials — Cruz, Pabilona, Francisco, and Baculando — are still liable as officers and owners of the other liable firms.
