.jpg)
By Mihar Dias November 2024
Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim has always been a master orator, spinning narratives with a blend of philosophy and righteous indignation. His latest defense of his overseas investment tours is no exception.
Anwar, in his own words, is astounded by the “crazy era” we live in, where critics dare question the propriety of his so-called “clean and transparent” initiatives. https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2024/11/1138506/anwar-defends-transparency-overseas-trip-labels-critics-living-half
How dare anyone raise an eyebrow at his Madani government's creative cost-sharing diplomacy?
The Jaman Edan Rhetoric
Anwar paints a picture of a topsy-turvy Malaysia where the corrupt are celebrated, and honest efforts to bring in investment are vilified. “Jaman edan,” he calls it, borrowing the Javanese term for a "half-crazed" era.
But one wonders if this half-craziness might apply to leaders who brush off legitimate concerns with moralistic scorn instead of addressing them head-on.
Surely it’s not unreasonable for taxpayers to ask why private corporations are covering 75% of government travel costs. Proton, Petronas, and Top Glove, we are told, joined these delegations and funded their own expenses. But wait—didn’t Communications Minister Fahmi Fadzil later clarify that the government still footed Anwar’s bill? Which is it? Are these companies philanthropists or mere spectators paying their own way? The mixed messaging only fuels suspicion.
Corporate Sponsorship or Favors in Disguise?
Anwar reassures us that this arrangement is above board, but corporate involvement in government delegations raises familiar red flags.
What assurances do Malaysians have that these companies won’t later receive preferential treatment? It's not like the names involved—Petronas, Proton, Yinson—haven’t been linked to government largesse before.
And let’s not forget the optics. Anwar’s government is quick to boast about cost-cutting measures, yet here he is explaining away private sponsorship as though the public has no right to question who’s footing the bill.
The Nurul Izzah Question
Then there’s the elephant—or rather, the "think tank"—in the room: Nurul Izzah. Anwar’s daughter conveniently joined the delegation in her “official capacity” with the Institute of Strategic and International Studies.
Official capacity or not, nepotism is nepotism. Did Malaysia really need yet another reminder of the Anwar Ibrahim family’s entrenchment in public life?
For a man who has railed against the old political elite for decades, Anwar seems to have no qualms embracing its perks.
A Lesson in Transparency
Anwar’s response, with all its lofty rhetoric, smacks of condescension. He dismisses critics as glorifiers of thieves and plunderers, as though any questioning of his government’s decisions is tantamount to betrayal. This kind of deflection might work on diehard supporters, but for the average Malaysian, it rings hollow.
If the Madani government is as clean and transparent as it claims, let’s see the receipts—literally. How much did these companies contribute, and what did their participation entail? How were they selected to join? And what protocols are in place to ensure these arrangements don’t compromise governance?
The Spin Cycle Continues
Anwar’s explanations might satisfy his loyal base, but they do little to inspire confidence in his broader audience. The public isn’t asking for perfection—they’re asking for clarity. Instead, they’re being treated to yet another episode of the Anwar Spin Cycle, where criticism is dismissed as noise and accountability is buried under grandiose moralizing.
In this jaman edan, perhaps the real question is: how long will Malaysians continue to tolerate being spun?
Mihar Dias is a content creator under the Newswav Creator programme, where you get to express yourself, be a citizen journalist, and at the same time monetize your content & reach millions of users on Newswav. Log in to creator.newswav.com and become a Newswav Creator now!
The User Content (as defined on Newswav Terms of Use) above including the views expressed and media (pictures, videos, citations etc) were submitted & posted by the author. Newswav is solely an aggregation platform that hosts the User Content. If you have any questions about the content, copyright or other issues of the work, please contact Newswav.