
THE prosecution team hoodwinked Vice President Sara Duterte and the Filipino people by withdrawing the impeachment articles on inciting to sedition and grave threats after painting her as a criminal and unfit to remain in office, ipso facto divesting her right to due process, as she was deprived of the chance to present rebuttal evidence to demolish the false accusations against her.
The prosecution’s malicious and strategic move, with the presiding officer’s concurrence, not only is constitutionally infirm and subject to constitutional challenge, but it also created a political backlash, as it was blatant and reeking of malice.
The prosecutors have infamously distinguished themselves by lacing their introduction and submission of inadmissible evidence with innuendo and black propaganda. What they lack in procedural expertise, they compensate with political theatrics designed to besmirch the reputation and character of VP Sara. Instead of proving their case through their witnesses, they punctuate their presentation with snide remarks and unsavory comments, always calling attention to themselves to get their two-minute shot at prominence.
The much older and obviously incompetent prosecutors are no match with the young and articulate defense lawyers, as they suffer in comparison. They violate sub judice rules and get away with it as the biased presiding officer tolerates it.
Despite the odds stacked against her, notwithstanding the power holders’ grip on those who will decide the fate of the respondentaccused, and who caved in to the threat of criminal prosecution on plunder charges and incarceration — two of them are already in jail while another is eluding an unlawful warrant of arrest issued by the International Criminal Court (ICC) — VP Sara, through her able defense team, shattered to smithereens the prosecution’s remaining impeachment article of unexplained and ostentatious display of wealth, as well as receiving double compensation while serving as the second official of the land.
The prosecution presented a witness who masqueraded as an expert in forensic analysis, not validated by any reputable organization nor confirmed by other experts in that field, claiming that VP Sara accumulated unexplained wealth totaling P817 million.
Using public documents like the statement of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALN), bank records, documents from the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) and Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC), he came up with misleading, if not false, conclusions on the alleged unlawful acquisition of wealth, only to admit on crossexamination that his analysis was based on certain assumptions yet to be established, and surmises anchored on wrong premises.
The prosecutors accused VP Sara of being a stockholder in a certain corporation (GenCorp), but the corporate papers and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) record show she is not. Their only proof is that she declared in her SALN that she is.
Obviously, the declaration was an honest mistake. She thought she had an interest in the aforesaid corporation owing to a previous capital investment that never materialized.
The prosecutors accused her of not declaring in her SALN real properties she owned. The city assessor’s office shows that the properties she declared in her SALN matched with the real properties recorded under her name.
The prosecutors claim that they are not the same properties because of certain insignificant discrepancies in the description and in the location; hence, they argue they are not the same properties and imply that VP Sara must have other undeclared properties. It cannot, however, show any other document evidencing that there are other properties registered under her name, which she has not declared in her SALN; hence, the inevitable conclusion that the questioned properties were properly declared.
She is also accused of receiving double compensation as vice president, but the local government record shows she received a salary deferential when she was still Davao City mayor, which means that what she received in the amount of P64,000 was her unpaid salary to which she was entitled to as then mayor of Davao City. The constitutional prohibition on double compensation was disproved.
They accused her of ostentatious display of wealth unbecoming of a public official because her husband lawyer Manases Carpio, on two occasions paid for a Tokyo dinner with friends amounting to P205,007 and gifted a performing basketball team players, of whom he was the manager, with athletic sneakers worth P256,882.50.
The defense witness testified that those who attended the dinner decided that the husband of VP Sara would initially shoulder the expense.
They reimbursed him for their shares.
Another witness testified that the gift given to the basketball players was Atty. Carpio’s way of rewarding them for a job well done in the basketball competition they joined abroad.
It was established that VP Sara was not present on both occasions. She had nothing to do with the two incidents. It should be emphasized that Carpio is not the one on trial. Moreover, as correctly pointed out by the impeachment court presiding officer, the amounts spent by Carpio are well within the SALN net income of VP Sara. As further articulated by four senator-judges led by Sen.
Pia Cayetano, by way of showing their disdain on the prosecution’s theory on the subject of expense, it is not wrong nor is it a crime to support athletes and give them generous recognition for their efforts. Sen. Robin Padilla was particularly incensed at the hypocrisy of the prosecutors-legislators who possessed expensive cars and mansions taken from the people’s coffers yet had the audacity to unlawfully accuse VP Sara of unexplained wealth.
It is glaring that the prosecution’s case against VP Sara has been shattered to pieces, but as in the case of her father’s ICC case, the political conspiracy engineered by their political enemies, as well as their insatiable lust to unlawfully continue in power at all costs, make the unfavorable outcome of the impeachment trial and the ICC trial predictable if not almost certain. Unless, of course, the gods of destiny unleash their sword of just retribution against those who deserve it.
The Filipino people eagerly, but dreadfully, await the end of this political theater. Its outcome will dictate the course that this country will traverse — even as the nation is in tatters or teetering on the brink
