
ON Nov. 13, students in universities across the country walked out of classrooms to oppose Pax Silica and the visit of United States President Donald Trump. Their protest asks questions that deserve answers. What does Washington stand to gain from the proposed industrial hub in New Clark City? What might the Philippines surrender in land, water, energy, tax revenue, or policy freedom? The master agreement is still being negotiated. The terms are not public. Scrutiny is necessary.
But scrutiny should be evenhanded.
Did we see a coordinated campus walkout on a comparable scale when a Chinese vessel struck and sank the Gem-Ver 1 in 2019, leaving 22 Filipino fishers in the water? When China Coast Guard vessels fired water cannons at Philippine ships? When, according to the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG), a Chinese ship aimed a laser that temporarily blinded Filipino crew members? As recently as September, the PCG reported that a Chinese vessel rammed a fisheries ship bringing fuel to Filipino fishers.
Some students and youth groups did protest. In 2024, the Student Council Alliance of the Philippines joined fisherfolk marching to the Chinese consulate. In 2025, a youth-led group rallied outside the Chinese embassy after another water cannon incident.
Those actions matter and should be remembered. Yet I have not seen a multicampus walkout on these incidents comparable to the one against Pax Silica. That is a question about the urgency we choose to display, not an accusation against every student who protested on Nov. 13.
One argument against Pax Silica is that it could reproduce the economic dependence cultivated under American colonial rule: the Philippines supplies raw materials and labor while foreign companies control production, markets and profits.
That is a legitimate risk. But if we ask whether a deal with Washington could become neocolonial, we must apply the same test to Beijing. Formal sovereignty does not prevent another country from gaining leverage through control of markets, financing or technology.
Look at where our ores go. In 2025, China bought 39.7 million metric tons of Philippine nickel ore and concentrates, 71.8 percent of exports in that category by weight. It took 65.4 percent of our copper ore and concentrate exports, and all recorded chromium ore and concentrate exports. When a single buyer takes that much, our producers have fewer alternatives if demand falls or buyers demand tougher terms. This concentration deserves at least as much scrutiny as the possibility of American dominance under Pax Silica.
Export concentration does not prove Beijing dictates commercial decisions or that every Chinese buyer acts as one. But dependence narrows a country’s room to maneuver. The question is whether the Philippines is building alternate markets and domestic processing, or settling into a role exporting bulk ore and importing higher value products. That is the same value chain critics fear Pax Silica might perpetuate. We should not condemn a possible future dependence while treating an existing one as ordinary trade.
The asymmetry deserves public debate too, openly.
The colonial analogy also asks who sets the rules. In 1909, the US Congress in Washington set Philippine tariff policy. Today, Manila can negotiate and reject unacceptable terms; BCDA has said Philippine law will govern.
That bargaining power is real, but it is not self-enforcing. Publish the final agreement. Let the public see who controls the land, what tax incentives are promised, where disputes will be heard, and what happens if a project fails to meet its obligations. Apply the same questions to every major deal with Washington or Beijing.
We should also correct a claim that has confused this debate: that Pax Silica already plans a massive AI data center in Capas. The proposed Clark Advanced Manufacturing Park is described by Philippine officials as a place for semiconductor assembly, advanced packaging, and electronics manufacturing, including components used in data centers. A factory that makes components for a data center is not itself a data center.
There are data centers operating in the Philippines already: VITRO Clark in the Clark Freeport Zone, separate from the proposed Capas site; AI-ready VITRO Santa Rosa in Laguna; Digital Edge NARRA1 in Biñan; and VITRO Cebu 2 in Mandaue. Rep. Ronaldo Puno has separately floated government data storage facilities under a bill for an Advanced Industries Zone in New Clark City. That bill remains pending in committee. Such a legislative proposal is not proof that a massive AI data center is already part of the current Pax Silica plan. Accuracy matters. Residents deserve straight answers about what is proposed, not alarm built around something officials say is not in the plan.
Their questions about water, electricity, displacement and community safeguards remain essential. The hub may involve factories whose resource demands and local effects must be assessed before approval. Consultation must mean more than explaining a decision already made. Communities must have access to impact assessments, a meaningful voice in decisions, protection for livelihoods, and remedies if commitments are breached.
I support Pax Silica only if its projects are environmentally sound and do not harm the communities that host them.
They must add value here by strengthening Filipino industries, transferring useful technology, and developing the skills of Filipino engineers and workers.
They must create decent, secure employment, protect existing livelihoods, and uphold labor rights. These are not optional benefits to be promised in publicity. They belong in enforceable project terms, with public monitoring and consequences for noncompliance.
The question is not whether the United States or China is capable of exploiting an unequal relationship. Both can be. The question is whether Philippine leaders can negotiate deals that expand our choices, retain more value at home, and protect the environment and the people who bear the costs. If Pax Silica means exporting raw ore while foreign firms capture the gains, reject it. If it brings technology, processing, decent jobs and enforceable safeguards, it may help loosen the dependence critics fear.
Protest Washington’s terms. Question Beijing’s leverage. Demand the same evidence and the same standards from both. If we are serious about sovereignty, we cannot defend it selectively.
Antonio P. Contreras is a professor at the University of the Philippines Los Baños and vice chairman of the board of PTV Network Inc.

