SCS claimants seen pursuing own strategies

WorldPolitics
17 Nov 2026 • 12:07 AM MYT
The Manila Times
The Manila Times

One of the longest-running English broadsheets in the Philippines

SCS claimants seen pursuing own strategies

ASEAN'S failure to agree on key provisions of a proposed Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea, coupled with China’s position on the negotiations, is likely to push the Philippines, Vietnam and Malaysia to continue pursuing separate strategies in dealing with Beijing, a Japanese defense research institute said.

In its China Security Report 2027: China and the South China Sea: The Dynamics of Maritime Issues, Japan’s National Institute for Defense Studies (NIDS) said differences among Asean members over the code’s geographical scope and whether it should be legally binding have stalled efforts to establish enforceable rules governing conduct in the disputed waters.

The report said the negotiations had made little tangible progress over the years, partly because China remained reluctant to accept rules that could constrain its actions and Asean members themselves could not agree on the scope and legal force of the proposed agreement.

The impasse reflects wider differences among the three Southeast Asian claimant states — the Philippines, Vietnam and Malaysia — in managing their disputes and relations with China, the report said.

The Philippines under President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has adopted a clearly confrontational posture toward Beijing, with bilateral tensions intensifying.

Vietnam, by contrast, has sought to manage disputes and avoid direct confrontation, while Malaysia has maintained a comparatively conciliatory approach toward China.

These differences stem from each country's circumstances, including its geographical position, history of relations with China, economic interests, security partnerships and domestic politics, according to the report.

Despite their divergent approaches, the three countries share a strategy of maintaining relations with Beijing while expanding security cooperation with the United States.

The Philippines is a US treaty ally, while Vietnam and Malaysia have also steadily deepened security cooperation with Washington while continuing to show consideration for China.

The report said balancing relations with the two major powers helps Asean states preserve their strategic autonomy.

It warned, however, that Asean's slow approach to the COC meant the three claimant states were likely to continue pursuing national policies based on their respective interests and constraints.

The negotiations began with the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea (DOC), which committed Asean and China to work toward a code.

The two sides endorsed a COC framework in 2017 and a single draft negotiating text in 2018.

Progress slowed during the Covid-19 pandemic, with online consultations making little headway. It took four years to complete the second reading of the draft text, the report said.

Indonesia accelerated the discussions during its 2023 Asean chairmanship, leading to the adoption of guidelines to speed up an effective and substantive agreement.

The third reading of the draft was completed about a year and a half later.

But the report said it remained uncertain how many more rounds of negotiations would be needed and whether the parties could resolve their differences over the code's geographical scope and legal binding force.

The Philippines' 2026 Asean chairmanship also failed to produce a final agreement, despite Manila making the COC one of its priorities.

Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said Sunday that Asean member states and China had reached provisional agreement on about 80 percent of the paragraphs in the draft, but the negotiations had entered their final phase without enough time to conclude them under the Philippine chairship.

“If we were given probably another five to six months, I think, we can finish that,” Lazaro said.

She said Malaysia and China were co-chairing the negotiations, while the Philippines had been shepherding the process.

Manila is placing its trust in Singapore, which assumes the Asean chairmanship in 2027, to complete the talks.

The NIDS report, however, cautioned that even reaching agreement among Asean members remained difficult, let alone securing China's consent.

View Original Article
Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved