
MANILA, Philippines — Senate Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero on Thursday called on senator-judges and lawyers in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial to exercise restraint in questioning witnesses, warning against conduct that could instill fear rather than encourage truthful testimony.
“While we may rigorously examine witnesses and test the credibility of their testimonies, we must refrain from resorting to a manner of questioning or to making declarations that elicit fear rather than candor,” Escudero said during the 43rd day of the impeachment trial.
Escudero reminded both the prosecution and defense that witnesses were entitled to certain protections under Section 3, Rule 132 of the Rules on Evidence, which applies suppletorily to the impeachment proceedings.
He said that while witnesses were required to answer questions even if their responses may establish a claim against them, they also have the right to be protected from irrelevant, improper or insulting questions and harsh treatment.
“The Chair wishes to emphasize that an answer which may be unsatisfactory is not inherently contemptible,” he said, citing Supreme Court rulings that have cautioned courts to exercise their contempt powers with the “highest restraint.”
Escudero also reminded his fellow senator-judges, including himself, that they were sitting as judges in a trial and must evaluate the evidence with impartiality and patience.
“We are sitting as Senator-Judges in a trial. Our rules behoove us to receive and evaluate the evidence with impartiality and, due to the often lengthy examination by both parties, with utmost patience as well,” he said.
He acknowledged that repeatedly hearing answers such as “I do not know” or “I do not recall” could be frustrating, particularly during lengthy proceedings.
“Unlike in inquiries in aid of legislation, an answer of ‘I do not know’ or ‘I do not recall’ may be extremely frustrating. It is one that we may encounter numerous times in a proceeding such as this,” Escudero said.
However, he said that the senator-judges could control how they assessed the witnesses' statements and testimonies.
“What we can control, however, is how we appreciate and weigh the testimonies and statements delivered before this Court,” he said.
Escudero also recalled his own earlier remark that his patience was wearing thin, saying the members of the impeachment court must remain mindful of their responsibility to conduct the proceedings fairly.
“The Chair therefore respectfully requests our distinguished colleagues, the counsels for the parties, including this representation, to exercise the restraint expected of us,” he said.
He said that the impeachment court owed it to the parties, witnesses and the institution to uphold fairness and respect regardless of their frustration or disappointment with the answers given.
“We owe it to the parties, to the witnesses, and to the institution we represent to conduct the proceedings still with fairness, dignity and respect, in spite and despite our frustration and/or disappointment with what the witness may or may not be saying,” Escudero said.





