Sore Thumb: Agreement on some features does not mean residents’ concerns have been addressed

LocalEnvironment
5 Nov 2026 • 2:39 PM MYT
The Sun Daily
The Sun Daily

For the latest news and features from Malaysia and the rest of the world.

Image from: Sore Thumb: Agreement on some features does not mean residents’ concerns have been addressed

FOR residents, Sore Thumb’s mature trees, wildlife and public beach are what make this coastline worth protecting. We want a welcoming park where people can enjoy nature safely, and we believe that goal is shared by the Penang State Government.

It is in this spirit that TBRA respectfully corrects Zairil’s statement, which gives the impression that all residents’ requests have been met except one. That is not an accurate reflection of the discussions or TBRA’s position at the meeting on Oct 27 2026.

While residents support several aspects of the developer’s proposal, substantive concerns remain outstanding:

(a) TBRA opposes cutting back any part of Sore Thumb and removing any mature trees or natural vegetation on the hill, as these actions will cause soil erosion and are not environmentally friendly.

(b) TBRA objects to retaining walls on the public beach above the mean high-water mark, as they will cause beach erosion and affect the coastline.

(c) TBRA objects to cutting into the hill to provide parking. TBRA proposes exploring the use of the current roundabout area for parking.

(d) Protect wildlife habitat. The toe should remain an undisturbed natural refuge, without concrete jogging tracks or other recreational structures. These are not minor differences over landscaping preferences. They concern the preservation of the natural promontory, its mature vegetation, wildlife habitat and public beach.

From TBRA’s research, the SSM document records Ng Wee Hean as a director and majority shareholder of Aptitude Consulting Engineers. He is also a shareholder of Lone Pine Residence through Summer Esplanade. When both the consultant and the developer are related parties, there is a clear conflict of interest.

TBRA therefore asks the State to allow engineers from NGOs such as SAM and TBRA to be part of the design team to propose less intrusive alternatives for stabilization and strengthening while preserving the natural landform. The recent Paya Terubong tragedy and the 2018 Bukit Kukus landslide have brought home the human cost of slope failures. These incidents make scrutiny more necessary in keeping with the State’s goal of a safe public park.

At the Oct 27 meeting, the developer was given the opportunity to present its proposed design. Yet residents were not given an opportunity to present their own detailed nature park proposal, formally submitted to the State Government in February 2026.

How can the State claim to have addressed residents’ concerns when the residents’ own alternative design has not even been properly presented and considered at the meeting? TBRA welcomes Zairil Khir Johari’s assurance that the State Government’s doors remain open. We therefore formally request an opportunity to present the residents’ proposal to him, PLANMalaysia and the relevant agencies, and for it to be fully evaluated before the final park design is decided.

We are encouraged by the Chief Minister’s statement on Facebook following his meeting with residents on November 6, 2025. “We had a constructive discussion on efforts to preserve the area’s greenery and natural assets. The state remains committed to supporting green initiatives.” We urge the State to translate this commitment into action TBRA is advocating a better public park — one that works with nature rather than reshaping or destroying it.

The public deserves a coastal park that protects its natural heritage, not one that sacrifices it. Our public appeal comes from a simple hope that future generations will still be able to enjoy the natural coastline we cherish today.

Zulfikar Aziz

Chairman, Tanjung Bunga Residents’ Association

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect those of theSun.

View Original Article
Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved