The bloodbath that became a cross-examination

Politics
14 Nov 2026 • 12:07 AM MYT
The Manila Times
The Manila Times

One of the longest-running English broadsheets in the Philippines

The bloodbath that became a cross-examination

SARA Duterte promised a "bloodbath." By Day 43 of the impeachment trial, her defense narrative was bleeding under expert cross-examination by private prosecutors. The six defense witnesses were supposed to strengthen her case. Instead, they left it weaker.

The first warning came before testimony. Dean Ralph Sarmiento, the defense's listed constitutional law expert, declined, saying he wanted to preserve his scholarship's independence and had not expected his views to be used in the proceedings. His withdrawal left the defense without the expert it had planned to present and foreshadowed the credibility problems of those who did testify.

Davao City assessor engineer Jaime Adalin was asked to identify the property prosecutors said had been omitted from Duterte’s statement of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALN) by matching it to the parcel in its title and deed. Discrepancies in location, acquisition cost and classification left the match uncertain: the deed said P6 million, the SALN P10 million; one record said lot with improvement, another said residential lot. A map and tax declaration did not establish that they concerned the same property, and Adalin could not identify photographs as showing it. Two barangay descriptions may refer to one area. That does not identify the lot.

Adalin did not resolve the central issue. He widened it. Senator-judges pressed him for records and travel details. His difficulty recalling a China trip, and the court’s warning over missing records weakened his account. Contempt and perjury sanctions entered the discussion. A witness who turns a property comparison into a maze leaves the defense with more to explain.

Engineer John Kenneth Enumerables, Samal’s assessor, was meant to reinforce the property defense. Instead, he could not establish that the property Manases Carpio acquired in 2013 was the one in the SALN. The title named Matanos, which he said did not exist. The deed and appraisal located the lot in San Isidro. The stated price was about P3.45 million, versus P4.04 million in the SALN. The SALN lacked a title or tax declaration number, leaving the court unsure where the property was, what it cost and whether it was the declared one.

Davao City accountant Vingelin Bajan explained the P64,194.72 paid to Duterte in 2023 as a delayed salary differential for her 2020 and 2021 service as mayor, following adjustments under the 2019 Salary Standardization Law. That addressed why the money was paid. It did not explain the yearslong delay, handwritten corrections or how the sum appeared in the records.

Questions about Bajan’s former accounting partnership then overshadowed her explanation. The firm later audited companies linked to the Duterte-Carpio family. Bajan struggled to recognize papers bearing her name and signature, including the firm’s founding documents and her withdrawal affidavit. A city accountant’s difficulty recognizing her own signed records turned the witness into a credibility problem for the defense.

GenCorp in-house counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay might have clarified corporate records and Duterte’s declared interests. She said Duterte was not a stockholder, but described a “loose investment” tied to the Jollibee Times Square branch and P2,142,369.14 returned from 2022 to 2025. She could not establish its original amount or terms. If it was an investment, where is its paper trail? If not, what was being repaid? “Loose investment” bears an impossible burden of explanation.

Kapunan’s question about the Constitution exposed another gap. Asked whether a sitting vice president may receive any emolument beyond her salary, Balucanag-Punay first said, “I prefer not to answer,” then said she did not know. Article VII, Section 6 permits prescribed salaries but bars any other emolument from government or any other source. Section 13 separately restricts outside office, employment, business, profession and certain financial interests. Balucanag-Punay could not explain how the payments or investment fit those rules. A corporate lawyer called to explain them should be able to account for both records and legal limits. “I prefer not to answer” was a poor substitute.

Lawyer Anel Antero testified about a P205,007.29 credit-card charge at Ginza Inakaya in Tokyo on May 19, 2023. He was traveling with Manases Carpio. Cross-examination established that Antero was Duterte’s close friend and supporter. He had no photograph to substantiate the claimed 11-person dinner, though he said others offered to pay and Carpio’s card was used. He produced no transfer record or acknowledgment that Carpio was reimbursed. Asked whether Carpio gave him P580,000 in July 2020, he said he did not recall. His testimony could not establish who attended, whether Carpio was repaid or what happened to the earlier transfer. It left the defense’s account unsupported where the money trail mattered.

Chadrin Parian testified about a P256,882.50 charge at the Nike Pavilion in Kuala Lumpur. He said he and Carpio traveled for their children’s basketball tournament. After the team won, the children chose shoes Carpio paid for. Parian confirmed Carpio also bought Nike shoes for others pictured holding boxes. Asked whether this reflected the simple-lifestyle standard cited for officials’ relatives, he could not speak for Carpio’s thinking, only that the children deserved the shoes. He cast the spending as parental support, but did not explain the additional purchases or address the scale of the expenditure.

By Day 43, the six witnesses had not given Sara the corroboration her case needed. The assessors could not identify the properties; Bajan struggled with her own records; Balucanag-Punay could not account for the investment; Antero had no reimbursement record and no recollection of a substantial transfer; and Parian defended the purchases without addressing their scale.

The pattern is plain: witnesses called to close gaps instead expanded them. The assessors left property identities uncertain; the accountant and counsel added documentary and payment questions; Antero left dinner attendance and reimbursement unsupported; and Parian’s defense of the shoes sharpened scrutiny of Carpio’s spending. The defense has made its case harder to contain.

There is no need to imagine laptops flying across a room. The questions are landing hard enough. Duterte promised a bloodbath. What she may be getting is the slow, painful death of a defense narrative, one answer at a time. Six witnesses later, cross-examination has shown how much the defense still has to explain.

The author is a professor at the University of the Philippines Los Baños and vice chairman of the board of PTV Network Inc., or PTVNI.

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved