
It must be bad luck – it cannot have been by design – that the Milburn report on youth unemployment dropped at the same time as the latest official figures on the state of the jobs market.
In his statement to parliament welcoming the report’s findings, Pat McFadden, the secretary of state for work and pensions, went out of his way to remind MPs that unemployment is down and employment is up.
He neglected to mention, however, that the number of job vacancies is down, and worryingly so. Indeed, at 690,000 unfilled positions, the figure stands at its lowest since 2014, excluding the Covid crisis.
Even more unfortunately for the government, and tragically for those most affected, the fall in available jobs was greatest in smaller businesses and sectors such as retail, hospitality and leisure – the very areas targeted by Mr McFadden as he seeks to implement at least some of the Milburn report’s recommendations.
This goes to the heart of the problem with Mr Milburn’s exhaustive and conscientious work. No one, including even the Conservatives, quibbles with Mr Milburn’s analysis or the humanitarian and patriotic spirit that lies behind it.
Something is clearly wrong if the UK has the highest rate of its young people not in employment, education or training across Europe, with the sole exception of Romania. That is nothing to be proud of. Almost one million people contributing nothing to an economy so desperate for growth is a huge loss, compounded by the cost of maintaining them on social security.
With the exception of a cohort of sick or disabled people, most of this generation wants to work, make a contribution to society and build a life and home for themselves and to start their family. It is not their fault that they find themselves in this predicament, and the longer they stay out of work, the more chance that their whole lives will be blighted.
As Mr McFadden, a minister fully in command of his brief, points out, some 60 per cent of young people in this category have never had any kind of a job; if they are workless at 20, they are more likely than not to be in that same grim position when they attain the age of 30.
All the many thoughtful, practical, well-researched recommendations in the Milburn report make perfect sense, and they will do some good. But there has to be some doubt as to whether they can achieve the stated goal of “Neet Zero” by 2037, remote as that seems in any case. With the important exception of the proposed training and employment subsidies, which should ameliorate skills shortages and encourage employers to take on a young starter, the Milburn report cannot “create” a single job.
That is no disrespect to Mr Milburn and his team, who have created a piece of work of historic significance, and one that resonates with so many families and friends of too many young people who feel rather abandoned by the system. The problem is that in too many places, the means simply aren’t there.
The Milburn “job guarantee”, a legal requirement for the state to provide employment for someone who has shown willingness and wants to take up an opportunity, sounded impressive when Mr Milburn announced it to Laura Kuenssberg last weekend. However, it is a guarantee of a job for just six months.
After that, it could be back to square one, with the risk of a lower entitlement to benefits. The state is not going to soak up the unemployed. The private sector will have to do much of that; but firms still won’t be able to if the skills and geographic mismatch continues, and growth remains sluggish.
As the job vacancies figures show, the British economy in large parts of the country is simply incapable of generating the kinds of entry-level opportunities, skilled or otherwise, that are needed – and it has not done so for some decades despite repeated plans from the Youth Opportunities Scheme in the 1980s to the Jobs Guarantee Scheme launched for long-term unemployed people. It is certainly a national challenge, but one that is more intractable in some places than others.
The Centre for Cities, a think tank, reports that a young person in Blackpool is three times more likely to fall into the “Neet” category than their counterpart in York. Young people in Birmingham are almost twice as likely to be inactive as those in Bristol. There is no number of training and youth experience schemes that will actually create jobs where they don’t exist. Investment in people does and will help; but the government will need to do as much, if not more, to get investment and enterprise into blighted, low-wage, left-behind communities.
Alan Milburn is now the most powerful man in government
Why getting young people into work is only half the battle
I was a Labour welfare rebel – but I’d support radical reforms now
Andy Burnham has said what no other PM dared to say about Brexit
Alan Milburn’s generous offer to the nation’s young comes with a catch



