
As might be expected from a Blairite former minister, Alan Milburn’s final report into youth unemployment is a masterpiece of inspirational phrasemaking. If creating jobs were as easy as minting soundbites, giving a better start in life to those 18- to 24-year-olds currently not in employment, education or training (the so-called Neets) would be a breeze.
That said, Mr Milburn’s ambitions are honourable and his motives unimpeachable, and there is no harm in putting his case in the New Labour style: comprehensible, memorable and vivid language. His work, in fact, recalls that of William Beveridge, who helped design the modern welfare state at the end of the Second World War, seeking to abolish the great social evils of that time – want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness. Sadly, some of these persist to the present day, and the key to vanquishing them for the rising generation is indeed work and a regular wage.
Hence the title of the Milburn Report, “From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation”.
No one should object to moving these blameless young people from “a lost generation to a work generation”, nor quibble with the aim of “Neet Zero” – reducing the present Neet rate of 13 per cent to a minimal, practically irreducible level of 5 per cent over a decade.
In an advanced economy suffering from skills and labour shortages, and consequential bouts of endemic wage inflation, it cannot be right that almost one million young people are languishing for lack of investment in their future. The vast majority wish to work, whether or not they suffer from minor illness or a serious disability, and the stories of individuals making hundreds of applications for work with zero success, and often not even a reply, are heartbreaking. Across Europe, only Romania has a worse record of neglect than the UK.
So far as his remit allowed him, Mr Milburn has risen to the challenge. In reasonable detail, he lays out the financial costs and benefits of his plan, and the means by which it can be implemented. Something of this scale needs both a national body to drive it forward and local authorities ready and equipped to implement it according to different and particular circumstances. What works in “left-behind” Blackpool might not be the best way forward in fast-expanding Cambridge, for example. Hence the creation of the Youth Opportunities Service, the “engine room of a Working State", and the local authorities already setting up Neets task forces.
After exhaustive research, Mr Milburn and his team have identified the kind of help British children and adolescents need to make a success of their lives as well as a contribution to the national economy. Neets, an ugly term in itself, are not some lumpenproletariat, but fellow citizens every bit as creative and diligent as older generations. They are all different and thus need as personal an approach as possible; they will receive a personalised participation plan and a named adviser if the Milburn recommendations are followed up. The two new legal guarantees, impinging on the state, would ensure progress, presuming they are enforceable. The “Opportunity Guarantee” would give a route into education, training or work, while the “Support Guarantee” would give the health, employment and practical help to take it up.
All of that should make some positive difference to the situation. But problems are already visible. This is because no matter how well prepared anyone is for their next job or course (at any age), if there are no jobs to be had in their area, even with tax breaks for employers, then the effort may prove futile. The Milburn “offer” is that if a young person remains Neet and paid work is realistically possible with support, the state should guarantee a paid six-month job through the Jobs Guarantee. Fine, yet what happens when the six months is up? There is insufficient work in the Milburn report on improving labour mobility, which is a major obstacle to reducing unemployment more generally. (Moving investment to the regions that need it was outside his terms of reference.)
Moreover, according to the report’s own figures, there is to be a negligible impact on reducing the welfare bill, even if everything goes right. Specifically, a £5.8bn annual investment by 2037, remote in itself, is to be offset by £3.6 billion of welfare savings and £2.4 billion of extra tax revenue and reduced benefit payments – saving just £200m a year in an annual welfare budget of some £330bn and rising. The £13.7 billion cumulative welfare savings in a decade’s time are thus far below what’s needed to help place the public finances on a sustainable footing. If the chancellor and the prime minister want to balance the books, they will need to look elsewhere.




