We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Food
13 Nov 2026 • 11:21 PM MYT
The Independent
The Independent

The world’s most free-thinking newspaper

We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Peeling back the plastic packaging of a supermarket Christmas sandwich has become a hallmark of the festive countdown, just as much as opening the doors of an advent calendar. Just like the best mince pies and mulled wine, festive sandwiches hit the shelves early to get us in the spirit and this years’ selection looks enticing. From the classic turkey with stuffing, and pigs-in-blankets to more inspired sarnies like a Boxing Day curry wrap, consider your lunchtime sorted.

To find the standout bites, we put a range of supermarket Christmas sandwich contenders through their paces. Rather than leaving the verdict to one pair of hands, the IndyBest team assembled around the testing table to chew, dissect, and crown 2026’s champion.

We looked for generous fillings, fresh bread and a sauce to bring it together. Read on for the best Christmas sandwiches to pick up when lunch rolls around.

Read more: Best supermarket Christmas food 2026

We tested a range of sandwiches for every taste and budget (The Independent)

The best Christmas sandwiches for 2026 are:

  • Best overall – M&S turkey feast sandwich: £4.25, Marksandspencer.com
  • Best budget buy – Aldi turkey feast sandwich: £2.49, Aldi.co.uk
  • Best chicken filling – Sainsbury’s Christmas cracker club sandwich: £3.50, Sainsburys.co.uk
  • Best wrap – Asda Boxing Day curry wrap: £3, Asda.com
  • Best vegetarian filling – Waitrose spicy falafel wrap: £4.15, Waitrose.com

Read more: Best supermarket mince pies, reviewed

M&S turkey feast sandwich

Rating: 5/5

Image from: We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Best: christmas sandwich overall

Why we love it

  • High quality ingredients
  • Generous amount of filling
  • Delicious turkey
  • Just the right amount of cranberry sauce

Take note

  • A bit pricey, and has gone up since last year

Reclaiming its crown from last year, the M&S turkey feast sandwich was the best Christmas sandwich we tried, with one tester proclaiming: it’s “absolutely gorgeous”. A classic you can’t go wrong with, it features all the familiar flavours of the 25th neatly layered between two slices of robust, tasty bread.

The M&S turkey feast is hard to beat (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

It’s generously stuffed, and while it may sit at the pricier end of the festive sandwich spectrum, the sheer abundance of filling makes it feel like good value rather than a splurge, plus one tester noted it felt homemade. The turkey is notably high quality — tender, well-seasoned, far from the bad rap of dryness the meat often gets.

There’s just the right amount of cranberry sauce too, providing a welcome sweetness that cuts through the savoury elements, and the stuffing is packed full of herby flavour.

Key specifications

Buy now £4.45, Marksandspencer.com

Aldi turkey feast sandwich

Rating: 4.5/5

Image from: We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Best: budget Christmas sandwich

Why we love it

  • Outstanding stuffing
  • Generous layer of turkey
  • Great value for money

Take note

  • Bread is not as tasty as M&S's

Giving M&S a run for its money, our testers found Aldi’s turkey feast sandwich just as, if not more, flavoursome for £2 less.

There’s generous chunks of flavoursome turkey breast with beechwood-smoked bacon, which wasn’t quite as tasty as M&S’s, and a nice amount of cranberry sauce.

This is a tasty budget sandwich (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

What stole the show for this turkey sandwich was its pork, sage, and onion stuffing which one tester noted tastes like Paxo’s mix aka the “ultimate Christmas”. Full on flavour and soft texturally, the peppery and herby layer was said to be “incredible” by a tester.

Overall, we’d pick Aldi’s Christmas sandwich for value for money, but M&S’s pipped it on overall taste.

Key specifications

Buy now £2.49, Aldi.co.uk

Asda Boxing Day curry wrap

Rating: 4.5/5

Image from: We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Best: christmas wrap

Why we love it

  • Great spice and smokey flavours
  • Good amount of filling
  • A bit different

Take note

  • Not very Christmassy for some

A bit of a curveball from Asda this year, we liked the boldness of its boxing day curry wrap that felt unique among other traditional festive sandwiches. While it’s not the most visually appealing, the curry flavours are smokey and have a good amount of spice.

If the flavours of Christmas for you include curry, this will be a hit (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

In the folds of a soft tortilla wrap, there’s a delicious butter chicken, tandoori onions, coriander and mint yoghurt mayo, which is full of flavour. For some of our testers this wasn’t the most Christmassy sandwich, but for others it was reminiscent of the flavours usually encountered on Boxing Day.

Key specifications

Buy now £3, Asda.com

Waitrose spicy falafel wrap

Rating: 4/5

Image from: We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Best: vegetarian Christmas sandwich

Why we love it

  • Lots of crunch and freshness
  • Delicious falafel

Take note

  • Not the most festive
  • A bit pricey for a veggie sandwich

Making a good Christmas vegetarian sandwich is a hard task – a nut roast between two slices of bread doesn’t say anything but dry. However anyone skipping meat won’t be disappointed with Waitrose’s spicy falafel wrap.

This veggie sandwich was full on flavour (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

Full of fresh flavour, the spinach wrap features a sweet potato and chickpea falafel, spiced red cabbage, spinach and rose harissa paste. The falafel itself has really good flavour and gives the wrap some robustness so it doesn’t fall apart. The red cabbage and rose harissa add some subtle warmth, and the spinach doesn’t feel redundant.

We took some marks off as this doesn’t scream Christmas (except the red cabbage, maybe), but that doesn’t take away fro the fact it’s a bright and elevated supermarket sandwich.

Key specifications:

Buy now £4.15, Waitrose.com

Tesco pigs in blankets sandwich

Rating: 4/5

Image from: We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Best: sausage Christmas sandwich

Why we love it

  • Peppery, sweet and salty in one
  • Good amount of filling

Take note

  • Sausages could be higher quality

A take on the favourite Christmas side, the Tesco pigs in blankets sandwich went down pretty well among the testers. We wanted a bit more saltiness from the bacon, and one tester found the sausages a little artificial tasting, but all in all it was a nice bite.

Fans of the side will enjoy this one (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

There’s a decent amount of filling inside the sandwich. The sausages have a subtle herby taste, complemented by the sweetness from the caramelised onion chutney. Texturally this is balanced with the sage and black pepper, and just the right amount of sauce.

Key specifications

Buy now £3.25, Tesco.com

Sainsbury's Christmas cracker club sandwich

Rating: 3.5/5

Image from: We tasted the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches, and loved this £2.50 one

Best: chicken Christmas sandwich

Why we love it

  • Peppery taste
  • Makes a change from turkey

Take note

  • Skimps on filling
  • Flavours are subtle

The satisfyingly named Christmas cracker club sandwich from Sainsbury’s sadly goes off with more of a fizzle than a bang. Despite the promise of the club format, the extra layer translates into more bread rather than more filling, which feels like a missed opportunity.

The flavours are a little lacklustre, and an extra hit of stuffing would have gone a long way in boosting the festive appeal. The spinach, meanwhile, feels largely redundant — included more for a token nod to health than for any real contribution to taste or texture.

The filling is nicely spiced (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

That said, it’s not without its merits. There’s a deep, spicy peppery kick running through the sandwich that works well with the chicken breast, giving it some much-needed character. And for anyone who doesn’t consider turkey their Christmas bird of choice, this makes a perfectly fine, if slightly underwhelming, alternative.

Key specifications

Buy now £3.5, Sainsburys.co.uk

What are the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches?

Stealing the show again, M&S’s turkey feast sandwich stood out. It has everything you’d want in a Christmas sandwich, being a comforting taste of the best bits of the day. It’s jam-packed with filling and is structurally strong, holding its shape rather than falling apart. That said, don’t overlook Aldi’s affordable version, and Asda’s Boxing Day curry wrap for something different.

How we tested the best supermarket Christmas sandwiches

When testing each festive sarnie, we considered the following criteria for every bite:

Why you can trust IndyBest reviews

Alice Reynolds is a writer at IndyBest and an expert in supermarket food and drink, having tested everything from the best supermarket pizza to best supermarket dark chocolate. She has seen every supermarket’s Christmas range, including supermarket mince pies, so knows what’s worth looking out for. Alice enlisted other IndyBest team members to help her with this festive challenge, many of whom have taste-tested supermarket Christmas sandwiches for years.

For more, here’s how to cook an entire roast dinner in an air fryer

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved