‘Appalling’ Broadway adaptation of Oscar-winning film savaged by critics

EntertainmentMovie
1 Apr 2026 • 3:18 PM MYT
The Independent
The Independent

The world’s most free-thinking newspaper

image is not available

  • A stage adaptation of Sidney Lumet's 1975 Oscar-winning film Dog Day Afternoon opened on Broadway on Monday night to overwhelmingly negative reviews.
  • Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright Stephen Adly Guirgis penned the adaptation, starring Jon Bernthal as Sonny and Ebon Moss-Bachrach as Sal.
  • Critics widely condemned Guirgis's interpretation for transforming the film's electric suspense into slapstick comedy, with one reviewer calling it an “appalling near-disaster”.
  • Reviewers highlighted a significant lack of threat in the production, despite its bank robbery premise, and a tendency to mock the characters.
  • Reports of tensions between Guirgis and producers emerged, with critics suggesting the 'undercooked staging' reflected an 'unresolved artistic dispute'.

IN FULL