Civil society and crafting the budget of our hopes and dreams

WorldPolitics
11 Nov 2026 • 12:05 AM MYT
The Manila Times
The Manila Times

One of the longest-running English broadsheets in the Philippines

Civil society and crafting the budget of our hopes and dreams

THERE is time for everything, according to Ecclesiastes, and a trifecta of events — outsized and corrupt congressional pork, a public fed up with massive official corruption, and the decision of many senators to implement a budget purge — paved the way for civil society to actively participate in the budget process. For the first time in the history of national budget deliberations, the welcome mat has been rolled out for the serious engagement of civil society in reviewing the national budget, watchdogs with a seat at the table.

When that finally happens — and that will be soon — it will be a glorious day for transparency and accountability, and for democracy. On how critically important a national budget is to the life of a nation, I keep recalling what Barack Obama’s budget chief Jacob Lew once said of the United States national budget: “Budgets are not just a book of numbers. They are the tapestry, the fabric, of what we believe. The numbers tell a story, a self-portrait of what we are as a country.” A national budget represents “the hopes and dreams” of a country, he added.

Civil-society leaders who will sit, observe, take notes and provide inputs to the senators determined to purge the P7.2-trillion proposed budget for next year of its bloated, corrupt parts should keep in mind that a pork-laden budget cannot represent the “hopes and dreams” of the nation. As such, civil society is mandated to help the senators identify the rotten parts — from the line items to the unprogrammed parts — then help provide the rationale for the excision of those tainted parts from the proposed budget. They should also help identify the proponents of the tainted allocations, then help the crusading senators publicly expose those proponents of vehement intents.

To carry out all these mandates, civil society should flex its anti-corruption muscles to the maximum. From all indications, civil-society leaders are ready to exert that ultimate flex. The anti-corruption group People’s Budget Coalition demonstrated its readiness during a recent testimony before the Senate finance committee. That hearing was held to find out what civil society believes were the objectional parts in the House of Representatives-approved version of the national budget. Even the anti-corruption groups not necessarily involved in the dissection of the proposed budget for next year were impressed with the presentation of the coalition during that Senate hearing.

The coalition did not only demonstrate a mastery of the tortured budget architecture, skewed in favor of lawmaker-crooks, as usual. They presented in detail the excess and the bloat that crooked lawmakers will exploit to extract grease money from contractors and suppliers. They have also masterfully coined the phrases that colorfully describe the corrupt parts that they believe could be in the figure of P1 trillion.

The first phrase was “politicized infrastructure,” which simply means pork barrel-funded infrastructure projects totaling P695 billion, spread across several agencies, primarily the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH). “Hard pork” is the shorter version of politicized infrastructure. The coalition says the House version has 6,200 “insertions” in the DPWH budget, with a funding total of P172 billion. Burned by the multibillion “Floodgate” corruption saga, the insertions are no longer the usual “flood-control projects.” This time, they are mostly “multipurpose buildings,” which the coalition says would serve not much useful purpose.

If not multipurpose buildings, the insertions proposed billions of pesos for “health facilities” and “farm-to-market roads” (FMRs) and “irrigation facilities.” Anti-corruption watchdogs know this: if lawmakers with vehement intentions cannot do “flood control” or “road signages” or “asphalting” because the evil intent will be so obvious, the next best alternatives are FMRs, irrigation facilities, health facilities, and multipurpose buildings.

After hard pork, the so-called “soft pork” comes as the complementary source of congressional kickbacks. The coalition has coined another term for soft pork, and it’s is a more apt one: patronage-driven ayuda (aid), with a total proposed funding of P210 billion. The patronage-driven ayuda is actually a slew of acronyms we are now familiar with: the usual Tupad, AICS, Maifip and PAFE. The disbursement of funds under soft pork usually comes with a guarantee letter from a politician — patronage politics that can be leveraged during election season.

The coalition said there was a “shadow pork” allocation under the unprogrammed allocation, billions of pesos in slush funds that can be devoted to projects identified by politicians. What are crooked politicians if they cannot cover all bases: hard pork soft pork, shadow pork.

The post-purge scenario, even if succeeds in excising the corrupt and compromised parts of the P7.2-trillion national budget, is still unclear to many Filipinos. What critical spending items would be funded once the tainted portion of around P1 trillion is scrapped and reallocated? Restoring the full funding for the foreign assisted projects is one. Funding game-changing health and education programs is another. Funding rail projects and other mobility/transport projects is another mandatory task.

What about allocating half a trillion pesos for research and development (R&D) and allied scientific research programs, with select research universities as the host of that inspired R&D work? We can dream, can’t we?

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved