
TOKYO: A brief, unsmiling handshake could be all Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi gets from President Xi Jinping this week during her first trip to China, with her remarks on Taiwan last year still rankling Beijing.
The conservative Japanese leader is likely to be denied a formal one-on-one meeting with Xi on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) meeting in Shenzhen, analysts say.
Takaichi is expected to be the only leader of a major economy not to secure a meeting with Xi, Kyodo News reported, citing Chinese sources.
Ties between the major Asian powers have deteriorated to historic lows after Takaichi suggested last year that Tokyo could intervene militarily if Beijing sought to take Taiwan by force.
China, which views the self-governed democratic island as part of its territory, retaliated with trade restrictions and warned its citizens against travelling to Japan.
Trump reportedly sought to play peacemaker in the dispute, subtly advising Takaichi to avoid provoking Beijing over Taiwan, the Wall Street Journal reported last year.
Xi-Takaichi talks at this week’s summit are “highly unlikely unless the Japanese side signals that Prime Minister Takaichi is willing to say something akin to an apology”, Bonnie Glaser, managing director of the Indo-Pacific programme at the Washington-based German Marshall Fund, told AFP.
“Beijing has so far signalled it is unwilling to work with Japan on any issues until the Japanese side takes steps to address China’s concerns about Takaichi’s statement,” she said.
Signs of detente
On Monday, Takaichi did not mention Xi as she listed the world leaders she planned to meet on the sidelines of APEC, which will mark her first visit to China as prime minister.
However, while high-level intergovernmental dialogue has largely stalled, signs of detente have emerged, with Beijing accepting visits by individual Japanese lawmakers.
When China’s top diplomat Wang Yi met former Japanese foreign minister Takeshi Iwaya in September, Beijing issued a statement demanding the “correction” of Takaichi’s Taiwan remarks, a softening of its earlier public calls for their “retraction”.
Behind the shift is largely the toll that strained ties are taking on China’s economy, Akio Takahara, a visiting professor at Tokyo Woman’s Christian University, told AFP.
“Beijing is realising that its (hardline) stance has gone nowhere, that it is only hurting its economy with more Japanese firms retreating,” the China studies expert said.
“I think that’s why Xi has started sending some signals,” he said.
The ball is now believed to be in Japan’s court, although the Takaichi administration has shown little inclination to return it.
That represents a stark contrast with the APEC summit in Beijing in 2014, when Xi held talks with then Japanese prime minister Shinzo Abe after a stiff handshake and months of painstaking diplomatic negotiations.
That landmark meeting improved ties, which had been frozen by Abe’s surprise visit in 2013 to a controversial Tokyo shrine honouring Japan’s war dead, as well as the previous administration’s nationalisation of disputed islands also claimed by China.
This time, however, although Takaichi’s official position is to remain “always open to dialogue” with China, there seems to be little desire to secure a face-to-face meeting with Xi, experts say.
Emboldened by rock-solid support from her conservative base, Takaichi has adopted a “staunchly anti-Chinese, overtly pro-Taiwan approach” rarely seen in previous administrations, Noriyuki Kawamura, a professor emeritus at Nagoya University of Foreign Studies, told AFP.
Although a snub by Xi risks embarrassing Takaichi, “it would also allow her to impress on her anti-China voters how badly she was treated, and potentially further fuel their support”, the expert on Japan-China relations said.
Reputational risk
Still, Beijing is adamant that Japan must budge.
China’s Wang ignored Japanese Foreign Minister Toshimitsu Motegi on the sidelines of an ASEAN conference in July, walking past him “without so much as a glance”, according to the Yomiuri newspaper.
Motegi later described the encounter as a “brief greeting” with Wang, but Beijing denied that any exchange had taken place.
For Takaichi to return the ball, China needs to send “more obvious signs” of rapprochement, such as releasing two Japanese businessmen arrested on suspicion of smuggling banned items, Takahara said.
However, Takaichi being given the cold shoulder by Xi risks damaging Japan’s regional reputation, Kawamura warned.
“It would make it obvious to Asian countries that Japan-China relations are now a destabilising factor in East Asia” and that “Japan’s power in diplomacy with China is declining”, he said.
Kawamura expects the two leaders to at least exchange a “cold” and “expressionless” handshake.
Denying her even that would contradict China’s image as “a country that has historically valued etiquette”, Kawamura said.
“If even that doesn’t happen, that would be tragic — proof that Japan-China diplomacy has severely gone off the rails.”



