
ELECTION lawyer Romulo Macalintal has asked the Supreme Court to restore the November 2026 Barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan Elections (BSKE), arguing that Congress may extend officials' terms but cannot use that authority to sidestep judicial safeguards on election postponements.
Macalintal stressed that he was not questioning Congress' power to set the terms of office. Instead, he is challenging the decision to defer the elections, which he claimed violated constitutional principles and the guidelines previously established by the high court.
“The win-win solution I am offering is two-fold: first, to declare constitutional the power of Congress to extend the term of office of barangay and SK officials; and second, to declare unconstitutional and violative of the 2023 Macalintal guidelines the consequential postponement of the November 2026 BSKE,” he said.
The motion challenges the Supreme Court majority's ruling on Republic Act 12326, which set the five-year terms and postponed the village and youth polls.
Macalintal argued that the high court committed a serious error in ruling that its 2023 guidelines in Macalintal v. Commission on Elections do not apply to the law simply because the postponement was treated as an incidental consequence of extending officials' terms.
He pointed out that the 2023 ruling laid down specific standards that must be observed in any future law or regulation postponing elections.
According to Macalintal, the guidelines leave no room for exceptions, regardless of whether postponement is the primary purpose of a law or merely an incidental consequence.
“The employment of the mandatory term ‘SHALL’ in the guidelines and the definitive word ‘any’ admits no exception,” he said.
He maintained that any election postponement must comply with the benchmarks set by the Supreme Court and be supported by compelling and justifiable reasons.
Macalintal argued that the November 2026 BSKE postponement failed to meet these requirements.
His proposal, he said, would reconcile the government's position on congressional authority over terms of office with the electorate's constitutional right to vote.
Under his proposed resolution, Congress, the Office of the President and the Commission on Elections (Comelec) would retain the authority recognized by the court, while voters would regain their opportunity to elect barangay and SK officials.
“On the other hand, the Filipino electorate will rejoice as their sacred right of suffrage is fully restored and vindicated,” he said.


