We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

5 Nov 2026 • 2:00 PM MYT
The Independent
The Independent

The world’s most free-thinking newspaper

We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

There’s arguably no food more festive than one of the best mince pies. Sweet and spiced, they are a staple of Christmas get-togethers, along with a glass of mulled wine – they even fuel Father Christmas on his night-long sleigh ride.

Despite the confusing name, mince pies these days aren’t filled with actual meat, but a sweet mixture of dried fruits like sultanas, raisins, orange peel, apples, combined with festive spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, and often steeped in brandy or rum.

They’ve been appearing in supermarkets since August (too early in my eyes), but which one should you buy? To guide your pastry-filled bite of Christmas, IndyBest’s shopping experts have blind taste tested supermarket mince pies to bring you the ones to munch on this Christmas.

Read more: Best supermarket Christmas food 2026

The choices come in at as little as 25p each (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

The best supermarket mince pies for 2026 are:

  • Best overall – Sainsbury’s taste the difference all butter mince pies: £3.50, Sainsburys.co.uk
  • Best filling – M&S collection mince pies: £3.50, Ocado.com
  • Best luxury – Waitrose no.1 brown butter mince pies with cognac: £2.66, Waitrose.com
  • Best for spices – Asda exceptional luxury mince pies: £2.84, Asda.com

Read more: What food to shop at M&S this Christmas

Sainsbury’s taste the difference all butter mince pies

Rating: 4.5/5

Image from: We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

Best: best supermarket mince pie

Why we love it

  • Buttery pastry
  • Filling tastes high quality, with a hint of brandy
  • Good value with a nectar card

Take note

  • Could have more mince meat

From its taste the difference range, the Sainsbury’s all butter mince pies are the best we tried. The pastry, though a little crumbly when cutting into it, has a really creamy, buttery flavour to it, which makes it a cut above the rest of the supermarket mince pies.

Sainsbury’s mince pies won us over (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

The mincemeat is balanced and has a decent booziness from the brandy, though it’s not too much. It's also not jammy and sticky like some can be.

These are excellent quality, whether that's for your everyday mince pie, or for bringing out at festive gatherings. They are a little more pricey than most supermarket mince pies, but you can make a saving if you use buy them using Nectar membership.

Key specifications:

Buy now £3.5, Sainsburys.co.uk

M&S collection mince pies

Rating: 4.5/5

Image from: We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

Best: supermarket mince pie for filling

Why we love it

  • Attractive, artisanal design
  • Nice depth from cognac, brandy and cider in filling
  • Tasty, crisp pastry

Take note

  • Pricier than other supermarket options

From M&S’s premium range, we were impressed by the collection mince pies. They have a rustic, artisanal look, with the holly design and dipped middle with a sugar dusting.

This looked like it had been made in a bakery (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

The pastry is crisp, buttery and really tasty, while the filling is one of the best we tried. It’s packed full of flavour and tastes high quality.

The cognac, as well as brandy and cider adds a warming depth, while the clementine juice was noted for its bright notes. At 58p per pie however, this one is the one of the most expensive supermarket mince pies we tried.

Key specifications:

Buy now £3.5, Ocado.com

Waitrose no.1 brown butter mince pies with cognac

Rating: 4/5

Image from: We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

Best: luxury supermarket mince pie

Why we love it

  • Lovely flavour from cognac and brandy
  • Sharper filling means it's not too sweet
  • Pastry has a good bite

Take note

  • Not much filling

The Waitrose no.1 brown butter mince pies with cognac stand out as a more grown-up affair. While the design is more minimal (and maybe less fun), the pastry is golden in colour with crimped edges, making it enticing.

This was the booziest one we tried (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

The pastry has a good bite to it, which is satisfying to eat, but the filling is the standout feature. Boozy, with fruit that’s a little sharper, it makes a change from overly sweet mince pies that appear every season. Our gripe, it could have been more generous with the filling.

Key specifications:

Buy now £2.66, Waitrose.com

Asda exceptional luxury mince pies

Rating: 4/5

Image from: We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

Best: spiced supermarket mince pie

Why we love it

  • Pastry has good bite
  • Spiced with cinnamon notes
  • Attractive design

Take note

  • Not overwhelmingly fruity

With an appealing star design on the top and crimped edges, these mince pies look the part. When biting into them, the pastry is very crumbly but still has a nice satisfying texture.

The cinnamon came through in the filling (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

The filling isn't very deep, but the mince meat here has a really delicious taste, and we particularly liked the warming cinnamon notes coming through. It's made with Valencian orange oil, giving it a really delicious flavour that's packed full of citrus.

Key specifications:

Buy now £2.84, Asda.com

Tesco finest mince pies

Rating: 3.5/5

Image from: We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

Best: crowd-pleasing supermarket mince pie

Why we love it

  • Soft pastry
  • Sweet, easy eating

Take note

  • Wanted more filling

If you’re hosting and need an easy crowd-pleaser, the Tesco finest mince pies are a lovely option to serve up, with an attractive snowflake design that will look good on a table.

These are quite sweet, which might be up your street (Alice Reynolds/The Independent)

While a bit thick, the pastry is so soft that it melts in your mouth. Soaked in French brandy and ruby port, the filling meanwhile is quite sweet, which will please some. The mince pies are good value at normal price, but if you have a Clubcard they cost a mere 25p each.

Key specifications:

Buy now £3, Tesco.com

Aldi specially selected mince pies

Rating: 3/5

Image from: We blind taste-tested supermarket mince pies – and there was a clear winner

Best: budget supermarket mince pie

Why we love it

  • Good value for money
  • Fruity filling

Take note

  • Too much pastry compared to filling
  • Missing festive spices

If you’re on a budget, Aldi’s specially selected mince pies are a nice option and come in at just 25p each. The sugar-dusted star shape design is a pretty touch, and would look nice on display.

They feel hefty, which is mainly due to the pastry that is a bit thick compared to the filling. Despite the price, it features luxurious ingredients like cognac and ruby port and the mince meat is fruity and sweet. Its overall flavour profile is best suited for those who don’t enjoy the typical festive spices, as it’s more subtle than most.

Key specifications:

Buy now £1.49, Aldi.co.uk

What is the best supermarket mince pie?

After digging into a range of festive treats, Sainsbury’s taste the difference all butter mince pies stole the show this year delivering the best all-rounder, with a tasty, balanced mincemeat and standout creamy pastry. Plus if you’re on a budget, shopping with Nectar brings the price down to just 29p per pie, which isn’t far off Aldi.

The M&S collection mince pies were also highly rated for delicious filling.

How I tested the best supermarket mince pies

Alongside IndyBest’s team of shopping experts, I blind taste-tested each supermarket mince pie, while considering the following:

Why you can trust IndyBest reviews

Alice Reynolds is a writer at IndyBest and an expert in supermarket food and drink, having tested everything from the best supermarket pizza to best supermarket dark chocolate. She has seen every supermarket’s Christmas range, so knows what’s worth looking out for. Alice enlisted other IndyBest team members to help her with this festive challenge, many of whom have taste-tested supermarket mince pies for years.

Getting ahead? This is what food to order from Sainsbury’s this Christmas

View Original Article
Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved