
A fly on the wall of the defense lawyers representing the vice president in her impeachment trial might have heard something like this, while they were prepping witnesses to testify:
GOOD afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. Today, we are going to prepare you for your upcoming stint as witnesses for the defense before a Senate inquiry.
In the movies, witnesses are often told to just tell the truth and everything will be all right. Forget that. If you receive a subpoena to appear before the Senate, your job is to protect your patron first, then, if possible, yourself, by not telling the whole truth. If you heed our advice, you will be fine — and your patron most grateful.
Tip No. 1. Cultivate amnesia. If they put you in a tough spot, say you can’t remember. For example, if one of the senators says, “Mr. Witness, we know you went to China earlier this year...” You say: “I did?” And if you’re asked who paid for the visit, just say, “I don’t know, your honor.” Or if you are asked what cities you visited in China, say “I’m sorry, your honor. I’ve been to so many trips as a public servant. I can’t remember the details of all of them.” You can offer: “I think we went to Beijing, but I’m not sure.” Don’t volunteer any further information.
Tip No. 2. Always appear respectful. Say, “Yes, your honor” or “No, your honor.” Don’t look smug or self-satisfied because that will just tick off the senators. Don’t smirk. Don’t argue with them. Don’t say their question is irrelevant. You don’t want to be slapped with contempt and spend days in detention.
Tip No. 3. Learn the paper shuffle. If confronted with a document, knit your brow and appear bewildered. Then keep rifling through the pages as if you’re lost. This will kill some time while you try to gather your wits. If you are asked, “Did you not sign this document in 2015?” Frown, and rifle through the pages again for a few minutes. Then revert to Tip No. 1. With your most apologetic face, tremulously say: “Sorry, your honor. I don’t remember. That was so long ago!” Dab your eye with a handkerchief to gain some sympathy. If they point to your signature on the document and ask if that is indeed your signature, do the paper shuffle again for a few more minutes. Then mumble: “I can’t recall, your honor.”
Tip No. 4. Feign ignorance. If you are confronted with damaging evidence, say you didn’t know anything about that. If you are the city assessor and you are asked about a piece of land that appears in your patron’s statement of assets, liabilities and net worth, just say you know nothing about it. If they back you into a corner, admit that your office did not conduct a site inspection of the property in question, so you really don’t know anything.
Tip No. 5. Delay is our friend. The longer this trial takes, the better it is for your patron. The public will get bored and lose interest if the proceedings take too long, so take your time when responding to questions. Never give a yes or no answer, because that will shorten your stay on the witness stand. Give long and winding responses that really don’t answer the question at all. This will lead to a long discussion among the senators, and you may be admonished to answer the question. Meekly say, “Yes, your honor” — then give another long-winded statement.
Finally, let me reiterate: truth is not our friend. Our patron has not taken the stand precisely because the truth will hurt us. We are here to provide cover. Don’t get caught in a lie because then you might be charged with perjury, but be as evasive as you can. If you do well, you might just get another trip to China.




