OPINION | Half in Prison, Half at Home: Mat Sabu's Noble Idea and the Coming Housing Crisis

Opinion
20 Nov 2026 • 10:00 AM MYT
Mihar Dias
Mihar Dias

A behaviourist by training, a consultant and executive coach by profession

Image from: OPINION | Half in Prison, Half at Home: Mat Sabu's Noble Idea and the Coming Housing Crisis
Mihar Dias on Gemini AI 

By Mihar Dias November 2026

There are moments in Malaysian politics when a politician says something so noble that you almost feel guilty for being cynical. Almost.

Agriculture and Food Security Minister Mohamad Sabu, better known as Mat Sabu, has offered to donate his entire ministerial salary to NGOs campaigning for a legal mechanism that would allow prisoners to serve half their sentences behind bars and the remaining half under house arrest. https://newswav.com/A2611_IIcuqM?s=A_A39IW96&language=en

How generous. How compassionate. How egalitarian.

At last, we may have discovered a way to make imprisonment more democratic. No more discrimination between the rich and the poor, the powerful and the powerless. Everybody gets a turn in prison, followed by a turn at home.

Mat Sabu says justice should not be the exclusive privilege of people with political connections, influential relatives or deep pockets.

I cannot disagree with the principle. If one convicted prisoner can serve the remainder of his sentence at home, why shouldn't others have the same opportunity?

But before we start celebrating, perhaps somebody should explain the logistics.

Malaysia's prisons are already accommodating thousands of inmates. Imagine half of them becoming eligible for house arrest. We could soon have a situation where the prison authorities are less concerned about managing prisoners and more concerned about managing residential addresses.

The Prison Department might have to establish a new division: Home Detention and Neighbourhood Relations.

Imagine the paperwork.

First, every prisoner must provide a residential address. What happens to those who have no permanent home? Do we put them on a waiting list for a PPR flat? What about the homeless? Do they remain in prison simply because they cannot afford a roof over their heads?

Then there are those whose families may not particularly welcome their return. A man convicted of domestic violence could find himself returning to the very household where his victim lives. Would the victim be expected to welcome him home with a cup of tea?

And what about prisoners who have no family, no home and no relatives willing to take responsibility for them? Perhaps the government should build a few thousand halfway houses. We could call them Rumah Peralihan.

Then comes the question of monitoring.

Will prisoners wear electronic ankle bracelets? Who pays for them? Who monitors the devices? What happens when someone switches off the electricity, removes the device or decides to take a little holiday?

Will the police be expected to patrol neighbourhoods checking whether former inmates are behaving themselves? Imagine a police officer knocking on a door at midnight.

“Encik, kami datang nak pastikan awak masih dalam tahanan rumah.”

“Ya, saya di rumah. Tapi saya sedang tidur.”

“Maaf mengganggu. Prosedur.”

Perhaps the police will need another department, another budget and another fleet of vehicles. We might even create a new professional category: Home Arrest Inspectors.

And what about the definition of half a sentence?

Is it half the original sentence or half the sentence after remission, good behaviour discounts, royal pardons and other adjustments?

If someone receives ten years, does he spend five years in prison and five years at home? What if his sentence is subsequently reduced? Does the calculation begin again? Will the Prison Department need an accountant, a mathematician and perhaps a constitutional lawyer to work out when somebody gets to go home?

I am not suggesting Mat Sabu has not thought about these things. I am merely wondering whether the NGOs he intends to fund have.

There is also a more fundamental question. Should every prisoner qualify for house arrest after serving half a sentence?

Surely the nature of the crime must matter.

A person imprisoned for a minor, non-violent offence is not necessarily in the same category as someone convicted of murder, rape, violent assault, organised crime or massive financial corruption.

A blanket policy could produce the absurdity of treating every offence as though it carried the same social consequences.

Justice is not simply about equal treatment. It is also about proportionality, public safety, rehabilitation and the rights of victims.

A thief who steals a loaf of bread and a person who steals millions belonging to the rakyat should not automatically qualify for identical treatment merely because both have completed half their sentences.

Equality before the law does not mean equality of outcome regardless of circumstances.

Mat Sabu's proposal comes at an interesting moment. Former Prime Minister Najib Razak has just begun serving the remainder of his SRC International sentence under house arrest following the High Court order.

Mat Sabu insists his proposal is not motivated by any personal dispute with Najib or his family. He says it is about the rule of law and preventing a two-tier justice system.

Fair enough.

But there is something rather Malaysian about the sequence of events. One high-profile prisoner goes home, and suddenly we are discussing how everybody else might enjoy the same arrangement.

It is almost as though we have discovered a new form of national equality: if one person gets to enjoy a privilege, the solution is to extend it to everyone rather than examine whether the original arrangement was appropriate in the first place.

Meanwhile, Mat Sabu says he will surrender his RM11,900 monthly ministerial salary, excluding his allowances, to support the NGOs until Parliament is dissolved.

That is certainly a gesture worth acknowledging. But I wonder why a serving Cabinet minister needs to finance NGOs to campaign for a policy that could presumably be discussed and developed within the government itself.

Is this a campaign outside the government to persuade the government to do something? Or is it a government minister funding civil society to lobby the government of which he is a member?

Malaysian politics has never lacked interesting arrangements.

Perhaps the NGOs should first establish a task force to study the proposal. They will need lawyers, prison administrators, social workers, psychologists, electronic monitoring specialists and probably a few property agents.

After all, somebody must determine whether the prisoner's house is suitable for detention.

And here is another thought. If a prisoner is allowed to serve half his sentence at home, does that mean he is free to receive visitors, watch television, order food delivery and continue running his business?

Will there be visiting hours? Will his movements be restricted to the living room, bedroom and kitchen? Can he attend a wedding? What about Friday prayers, medical appointments and family holidays?

Perhaps we should issue a House Arrest Handbook.

Chapter One: You May Leave Home Only With Permission.

Chapter Two: Your Neighbour Is Not Your Prison Warden.

Chapter Three: Do Not Post Holiday Photographs on Social Media.

I am being facetious, of course. But these are serious questions requiring serious answers.

I support the principle that justice should not depend on one's wealth, political connections or family name. If a proper house arrest system is introduced, it must have clear eligibility criteria, independent oversight, transparent procedures and safeguards for victims and the public.

But let us not confuse a noble gesture with a workable policy.

Mat Sabu has offered his salary. That is commendable. Now we need a detailed proposal, not merely a slogan.

Otherwise, we may end up with a new Malaysian institution where prisoners are released from one address only to be supervised at another, while taxpayers foot the bill.

Perhaps the greatest irony is that we are spending so much time figuring out how to make imprisonment more comfortable when we should be spending at least as much effort ensuring that people do not end up in prison in the first place.

And if house arrest is to become the next great Malaysian reform, I have one final question.

Will the prisoners be allowed to choose their own houses, or will the government provide them?

Because if the latter is the case, I can already imagine the queue.

And knowing Malaysia, somebody will probably ask whether the house comes with a swimming pool.


Mihar Dias (mihardias@gmail.com) is a content creator under the Newswav Creator programme, where you get to express yourself, be a citizen journalist, and at the same time monetize your content & reach millions of users on Newswav. Log in to creator.newswav.com and become a Newswav Creator now!

The User Content (as defined on Newswav Terms of Use) above including the views expressed and media (pictures, videos, citations etc) were submitted & posted by the author. Newswav is solely an aggregation platform that hosts the User Content. If you have any questions about the content, copyright or other issues of the work, please contact creator@newswav.com.

Newswav Malaysia Best News App

Newswav is an online content aggregator and obtains its content from different online sources. The content in the app do not belong to Newswav nor do they reflect the opinions of Newswav and its staff. Your use of this app indicates your understanding and acceptance of this information.

Newswav Sdn. Bhd. (201701008480 (1222645-M)) 2026 All Rights Reserved